Fishstores.org
StatesMapSearchNear meToolsGuidesSpecies
Fishstores.org

The most comprehensive directory of brick-and-mortar fish stores in the United States.

Find Fish Stores

  • Fish Stores Near Me
  • Browse by State
  • Nationwide Store Map

Care Guides

  • Freshwater fish & shrimp
  • Saltwater & reef
  • Tanks & equipment
  • Troubleshooting
  • Browse all guides →
  • Species directory →

Resources

  • About Us
  • Email Us
  • Sitemap
© 2026 fishstores.org. All rights reserved.
Privacy PolicyTerms of ServiceAccessibility
  1. Home
  2. ›
  3. Best
  4. ›
  5. Freshwater
  6. ›
  7. New York

Freshwater · New York

Best freshwater fish stores in New York.

62 stores

62 stores specializing in freshwater fish, plants, and aquarium supplies across New York. Ratings, hours, and directions for every shop.

Editor's pick

Highly rated specialists

Best-reviewed freshwater shops in New York — every one of them keeper-vetted, not algorithmic.

Rated 4.5+
No. 01

Pacific Aquarium & Plant

5.0
New York, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 02

Aquatic Haven

5.0
Fulton, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 03

Fluid Dynamics Aquarium Services and Store

5.0
Deer Park, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 04

Dynamic Tank Design

5.0
Freeport, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 05

City Island Aquarium Tropical Fish Sales

5.0
Bronx, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 06

Luv A Lotl Axolotl/Reptile Boutique

5.0
Webster, NYFreshwaterVisit listing

The full list

Every freshwater store in New York

Sorted by rating — every verified specialist in the state.

62 stores
No. 01

Pacific Aquarium & Plant

5.0
New York, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 02

Aquatic Haven

5.0
Fulton, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 03

Fluid Dynamics Aquarium Services and Store

5.0
Deer Park, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 04

Dynamic Tank Design

5.0
Freeport, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 05

City Island Aquarium Tropical Fish Sales

5.0
Bronx, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 06

Luv A Lotl Axolotl/Reptile Boutique

5.0
Webster, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 07

Machias Outdoors

5.0
South Wales, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 08

Complete Aquarium

4.9
Bedford Hills, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 09

A & R Reptiles and Aquariums

4.9
Elmsford, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 10

Avalon Exotics

4.9
North Tonawanda, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 11

Underground Aquaticz

4.9
West Babylon, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 12

Aquarium Network

4.9
Bellmore, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 13

Island Fish & Reef

4.9
Bohemia, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 14

Overboard Aquatics

4.9
Port Jervis, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 15

Advanced Marine Aquatics

4.8
Albertson, NYSaltwater · FreshwaterVisit listing
No. 16

Fishtopia

4.8
Staten Island, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 17

Low Tide Corals & Aquatics

4.8
Syracuse, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 18

South Shore Tropicals

4.8
Lindenhurst, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 19

Caribbean Forest LLC

4.8
Rochester, NYSaltwater · FreshwaterVisit listing
No. 20

FISH ADDICTS NYC

4.8
Brooklyn, NYFreshwater · Saltwater · BrackishVisit listing
No. 21

New York Reef Aquatic

4.7
Flushing, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 22

Buckley's Fish Room

4.7
Ballston Spa, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 23

Benson's Pet Center

4.7
Albany, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 24

Mid-Atlantic Stocking

4.7
Candor, NYPond · FreshwaterVisit listing
No. 25

Aquatics and Exotics Pet Shop llc

4.7
Ilion, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 26

PREDATORY FINS

4.7
Copiague, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 27

Aquarium Solutions 101

4.7
Wappingers Falls, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 28

Pet Friendly

4.7
Hilton, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 29

Eddie's Aquarium Centre

4.6
Cohoes, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 30

ABC Reefs

4.6
Solvay, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 31

Coral Sea Aquatics

4.6
Orchard Park, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 32

The Fish Place

4.6
North Tonawanda, NYFreshwater · Saltwater · BrackishVisit listing
No. 33

Buffalo Pet Supply

4.6
Tonawanda, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 34

Marine Oasis

4.6
Spencerport, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 35

Pet World & Aqua Shoppe

4.6
Rochester, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 36

Sondra’s City Zoo

4.6
Elmira, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 37

Ellicottville Aquatics LLC. Pet Store

4.6
Great Valley, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 38

Tropical Showcase

4.5
Hicksville, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 39

Jawz Aquarium

4.5
Elmsford, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 40

Amazing Aquarium

4.5
Brooklyn, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 41

Creature Comforts

4.5
Binghamton, NYFreshwater · Saltwater · PondVisit listing
No. 42

Country Critters Ltd

4.5
Patchogue, NYFreshwater · Saltwater · PondVisit listing
No. 43

Rockland Aquarium

4.5
Bardonia, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 44

Empire Aquatics

4.5
Canastota, NYFreshwater · Saltwater · PondVisit listing
No. 45

South River Aquarium

4.5
Brooklyn, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 46

Aqua Hut Inc

4.4
Coram, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 47

The iFISH Store

4.4
Richmond Hill, NYFreshwater · PondVisit listing
No. 48

Blackwinds Pet Supplies

4.4
Niagara Falls, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 49

Brooklyn Zoo & Aquarium Pet Store

4.4
Brooklyn, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 50

The Pet Store

4.4
New York, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 51

Kissena Aquarium Inc

4.4
Flushing, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 52

Pet Resources

4.4
Bronx, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 53

Pete's Aquariums & Fish

4.3
Fishkill, NYFreshwater · Saltwater · PondVisit listing
No. 54

Beital's Aquariums Sales, Services & Ponds

4.3
Pearl River, NYFreshwater · Saltwater · PondVisit listing
No. 55

Tri-County Tropicals, Inc.

4.3
Richmond Hill, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 56

Paradise Aquarium

4.2
Ridgewood, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 57

Monster Aquarium Inc - Shop in Queens New York

4.2
Flushing, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 58

The Aquarium Shop Westbury

4.2
Westbury, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 59

Total Aquariums

4.2
Oceanside, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 60

Pet World

4.0
East Rochester, NYFreshwater · Saltwater · PondVisit listing
No. 61

Aquarius Aquariums

3.9
New York, NYFreshwater · PondVisit listing
No. 62

B.T.J.'s Jungle

3.9
West Islip, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing

By city

Brooklyn4·New York3·Flushing3·Bronx2·Elmsford2·North Tonawanda2·Rochester2·Richmond Hill2
View all fish stores in New York

More in New York

SaltwaterCoralLive PlantCichlidKoi & PondInvertebrateRare Species