Walking into A & R Reptiles and Aquariums in Elmsford, New York, you're immediately greeted by a large display tank stocked with eye-catching fish — and usually by an equally enthusiastic staff member ready to help. This Westchester County shop, run by owner Rich (Richie to regulars), has built a devoted following among freshwater hobbyists and reptile keepers who drive from as far as the Bronx to shop here. The freshwater selection is impressive and well-curated.
Cichlids are a particular strength, and you'll find livebearers like guppies and mollies, bettas, catfish (including a massive striped Raphael named Hercules), axolotls, and invertebrates such as African dwarf frogs and mystery snails. Live plants are stocked regularly, and the store carries live black worms and other quality foods. Every tank in the shop is meticulously maintained — a detail reviewers mention again and again — and the fish are visibly healthy.
What sets A & R apart from the chain stores is the depth of guidance customers receive. Staff member Josh is frequently praised for spending real time with first-time tank owners, walking families through proper setups and even refusing to sell a fish he didn't think looked healthy enough. John has been known to spend half an hour discussing captive-bred reptiles with curious visitors.
Rich himself helped one customer select and set up a 75-gallon tank with stand and matching canopy that still looks brand new a year later. Pricing is consistently described as reasonable — often cheaper than the big-box competition for items like tank lids and supplies. The store stocks Zoo Med terrariums and a range of dry goods that rival or exceed what you'd find at larger retailers.
A & R serves a real need in the Westchester area for a freshwater fish and reptile shop where the animals come first and the advice is grounded in genuine experience. 9 rating across 140 reviews isn't accidental — it reflects a store where customers feel heard, fish thrive, and people keep coming back.
Yohann Abitbol
12 reviews
First time here will definitely be back, Rich was quick to welcome me and ask of i had any question. Also there is a great selection of reptiles and cichlids, already planning my trip back!
Jessica Dieckman
14 reviews
This is a fantastic store. The owner and staff are all very knowledgeable. All the animals and tanks are well cared for. My daughter got the Axolotl of her dreams that she saved up two years for. We got all our supplies here with detailed care instructions. They answered all my questions. I could not recommend this wonderful place enough. They have an enormous selection too. Thank you Richie and everyone there!
Mark Segal
3 reviews
Great people and enclosures/aquariums! Highly Recommend!!!
Carlos Franco
3 reviews
Truly a gem in Westchester to get quality fish and reptiles. Their selection of fish and especially reptiles is an amazing. Prices are very reasonable and staff is knowledgeable. A & R is my go to for all my exotic and fish needs.
Nico
I have come here to buy lots of fish and plants and upgrades for my tank and the fish are kept in amazing conditions and these people know how to give proper care for them. Definitely going back to get more fish over the years!
rocky mohabir
6 reviews
Really great store. The staff was super helpful and knowledgeable. The only store for my fish needs I will be going to.
Matt Dennis
56 reviews
Very very helpful staff. Walked me through the right fish my first aquarium. Also bought a lid from them and its was cheaper than petro. Happy i found these guys
Andre Fuller
2 reviews
A&R reptiles and aquariums are the best pet store I've ever visited including the one I used to work for 5 years. I bought 2 African dwarf frogs a mystery snail and live black worms 🪱. My animals are thriving, and I already taught them how to come to me for food when I tap the glass it only took 3 days. I will be buying a leopard gecko next. And then a crested gecko.
lukas idk
2 reviews
When you first walk in you see a huge tank filled with awesome fish. The staff is also great answering all of my questions. I have bought many fish from here and will continue to do so.
Priscilla Albano
4 reviews
Great pet store with very friendly and knowledgeable staff! You'll get help as soon as you walk through the door and they take the time to listen to exactly what you need before assisting you. Not to mention they also have some BEAUTIFUL aquarium displays and let me take my time looking at all of their lovely sea pancakes~!!
Note: Store information and services may change. Always call (914) 372-7101 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting A & R Reptiles and Aquariums.
Take control of your listing to update info and respond to reviews.
Claim This ListingFind on Map
116 S Central Ave A, Elmsford, NY 10523
February 7, 2026
Verified Data
Information verified through Google Places API and community contributions.
Other aquarium shops nearby worth checking out