Tucked into Fishkill, New York, Pete's Aquariums & Fish is a locally owned operation that punches well above its weight — particularly through its thriving online department. Owner Pete has built a reputation as one of the most trusted livestock dealers in the hobby, and his team, especially online coordinator Michael, backs that up with meticulous customer service that reaches hobbyists as far as Utah. The physical shop isn't flashy, but the care behind the scenes is evident.
Tanks are clean, fish are healthy, and Pete keeps medications on hand for customers dealing with parasitic outbreaks at home. The freshwater side stocks quality live plants like Java fern and tank mates like mystery snails — great for planted tanks and betta setups. On the saltwater side, the inventory gets genuinely interesting: Achilles tangs (a notoriously difficult species), zebra moray eels, emperor angels, regal angels, queen angels, octopuses, and corals.
Reviewers consistently note that even sensitive marine species arrive eating immediately, a testament to Pete's quarantine process and careful acclimation protocols. The online store is where Pete's really shines for out-of-state buyers. Packaging is meticulous, shipping schedules are coordinated personally, and the livestock arrives in excellent condition.
Multiple customers describe repeat purchases with zero disappointment. If something isn't listed on the website, a phone call to Pete often results in him sourcing it — a level of personal service that's increasingly rare in the age of big online retailers. Staff take the time to walk customers through proper care, whether it's octopus tank safety or acclimating a delicate tang.
The emphasis is clearly on responsible fishkeeping over quick sales. Pond enthusiasts are also served, rounding out a shop that covers freshwater, saltwater, and pond needs under one roof. For hobbyists in the Hudson Valley or anyone shopping online for quality marine and freshwater livestock with real human support behind it, Pete's delivers — literally and figuratively.
Mario Rodriguez
22 reviews
Pete is always incredibly informative and helpful every time I stop by. He has always been reliable in offering support and having medications handy for when Im dealing with a parasitic outbreak. The fish he sells are very healthy and well kept. I will be sure to only shop with Pete at his store.
kyle wang
18 reviews
I bought some mystery snails and some Java fern from here about a month ago. They've been doing great for my Betta tank. The Java fern propagated as well. Super glad I came here to get some good, healthy tank mates for my Betta
Johnathan Carr
9 reviews
Absolutely outstanding experience at Pete’s Aquariums & Fish. I purchased an octopus, and the staff was incredibly knowledgeable, patient, and genuinely cared about the animal’s well-being. They took the time to explain proper acclimation steps, tank safety, and how to ensure the health of both the octopus and existing livestock. You can tell they prioritize responsible care and education, not just sales. Highly recommend for anyone serious about marine life.
Christian Dixon
7 reviews
Pete is by far one of the most reputable and genuine fish dealers on this Earth! I buy from him every year and he never disappoints! Can’t recommend him enough!
Peter Cole
16 reviews
Very good store and have great fish selection at good prices. Michael is Great! He runs the Online department and is very knowledgeable and helpful! I highly recommend this store to anyone that values quality livestock and great service.
Adam Bogin
5 reviews
Recently purchased a Zebra moray eel online from them. It was carefully packaged and healthy appearing. The fish acclimated almost immediately to the tank staking out a territory in the rockwork . Appetite is good and no problems with tank mates. A beautiful addition to the aquarium. I will definitely order from them again.
Tommy Arnold
2 reviews
Hello I have not been here but do you guys sell jellyfish by chance
Cindy Long
6 reviews
It’s Worth the money
Shawn Recker
9 reviews
I did not get my full order.
Jonaid Lone
3 reviews
I ordered a notoriously difficult fish (Achilles Tang) from Pete’s, and I was blown away by the quality. The fish arrived healthy, well-fed, and even ate right away, which is often a challenge with this species. This was my first order from Pete’s, and it definitely won’t be my last. The packaging and overall condition of the fish clearly showed the team’s care and attention to detail. Customer service was outstanding and very helpful in coordinating the shipping schedule. Great job all around!
Note: Store information and services may change. Always call (917) 405-9428 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Pete's Aquariums & Fish.
Take control of your listing to update info and respond to reviews.
Claim This ListingFind on Map
973 Main St, Fishkill, NY 12524
February 7, 2026
Verified Data
Information verified through Google Places API and community contributions.
Other aquarium shops nearby worth checking out