Tucked away in Candor, New York, Mid-Atlantic Stocking is a pond fish supplier that has built a loyal following among private pond owners across the region. Run by Alex and his team, the operation specializes in stocking ponds with species like largemouth bass, bluegill, channel catfish, crappie, koi, and fathead minnows — the core cast for building a healthy freshwater pond ecosystem. The ordering process is straightforward.
Customers can place orders online or by phone, and Mid-Atlantic ships fish overnight on Wednesdays or arranges pickup at scheduled route stops. Multiple reviewers describe receiving bags of lively, healthy fish that acclimate quickly to their ponds. One customer reported fingerling bass growing to over two pounds within a year.
Another raved about hand-selected koi in the 8-14 inch range arriving in beautiful mixed assortments at prices significantly lower than local suppliers. Alex is the constant thread through nearly every review. Customers describe him as patient, knowledgeable, and genuinely invested in helping pond owners choose the right species and quantities for their water.
He's helped customers plan initial pond stockings, advised on pond ecosystem balance, and remained available for follow-up questions years after the first purchase. Several reviewers are on their third or fourth year of repeat orders, stocking both spring and fall. Mid-Atlantic also sells fish food and pond care products, and offers home delivery as a newer option alongside their established route-based pickup system.
The company serves customers managing everything from quarter-acre backyard ponds to 3+ acre properties. It's worth noting that live fish shipping carries inherent risks — a small number of reviewers reported DOA fish, particularly with more delicate species like crappie. But the overwhelming majority describe near-perfect survival rates and fish that thrive for years.
For pond owners in upstate New York and beyond looking to stock or restock their water, Mid-Atlantic Stocking delivers both the fish and the expertise to back them up.
Bob LeMay
7 reviews
I recently got more bluegill for my quarter acre pond.About two years old,I started stocking my pond and contacted Mid -Atlantic for a start up .I talked with Alex and he was very cordial and patient.I have called him several times since and he was very helpful.When I got another purchase of fish ,I found the driver to be courteous and professional.I found their ad in the NY Outdoor News ,a hunting/ fishing newspaper.I love their service and products.I would highly recommend Mid -Atlantic to home owners who are thinking of stocking their private ponds.Thank you for your quality service and products
Jacquelyn Eyster
11 reviews
I recently received Koi fish in various sizes 8-10 inches and 12-14 inches and they were beautiful! The lengths vary based upon their catch! Fish were healthy, happy, and the process was super easy! There was great communication and clarification on pricing, delivery times of pickups, and the staff truly are considerate and very passionate about their jobs! The lady told me she hand selected mine and she really did a beautiful job giving me a mixed assortment! Will be returning!
Shawn Wall
10 reviews
I bought fish from them about 2 years ago. It was 15 bass, 15 catfish, 12 bluegill and bout 200 minnows or maybe it was fatheads, but anyways i got a bunch of fish. Not really sure how everything worked and i was worry some were going to show up dead, but everything worked perfectly! I met them on their route, came home and put them in the pond. 2 years later these things are huge they had to grow over a foot since I got them! AND! In the whole time I had them I lost one catfish and that was a few days after first introducing them to the water. But that could have been anything. But, They package them really nicely and all in all it was a very easy to place an order and pick up and I’m very happy!
Tom Gentile
4 reviews
I’ve purchased from Atlantic supply the last three years. They make it very easy to keep my pond stocked. Never had an issue and fish are always very healthy. I will be ordering again this month for the 4th year
Stephen Shaben
Excellent company! Have ordered fish several times now and have had only excellent service and quality fish. Highly recommend for any of your pond needs. Thank you very much to Alex and the whole Mid-Atlantic Stocking Team.
Eileen and Richard Conte
3 reviews
Have been getting Koi from Mid-Atlantic for a couple years. Always in good condition. Also picked up a couple of Channel Cats that are getting quite large. Tried adding some Bluegills also. Very satisfied with their pick-up/delivery system.
Dave Pascarella
19 reviews
Great company very responsible always on time. Nice quality fish. Try to get a few every year.
James metz jr
12 reviews
Ordering online was very easy. Found the pricing to be fair and not as expensive as I thought it was going to be. I purchased five largemouth bass as a gift for my boss for the pond and our new shop. When the fish arrived they were very much alive and active. I acclimated them to the pond for about 20 minutes, release them and they swam right off. We will definitely be ordering from you again as well as the company that I work for will be ordering too. Thank you very much!
Joe Mcsorley
13 reviews
I wish I found this place a while ago. I got koi that were 1/3 the price of local suppliers and they are beautiful. I also got blue gill and minnows and all are thriving. This is now my go to place for fish. Thanks.
Filipe M. Pereira
136 reviews
Best place to source your fish! Customer service second to none! Already looking forward to my next stocking. Thanks Alex!
Note: Store information and services may change. Always call (607) 566-1269 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Mid-Atlantic Stocking.
Take control of your listing to update info and respond to reviews.
Claim This ListingFind on Map
257 Nagel Hill Rd, Candor, NY 13743
February 7, 2026
Verified Data
Information verified through Google Places API and community contributions.
Other aquarium shops nearby worth checking out