About
Tucked into Port Jervis, New York, Overboard Aquatics is a compact but deeply curated shop run by owners Tyler and Bill — two guys whose passion for aquatic life is practically contagious. Customers routinely drive 40 minutes or more to get here, and the reason is simple: the level of care and expertise packed into this small storefront is remarkable. The shop leans heavily toward marine life, with a strong selection of coral frags and saltwater fish that draws reef hobbyists from across Orange County and even neighboring Pennsylvania.
One customer noted purchasing bio balls that had been seasoning in the store's own sump for two years — the kind of detail that signals people who actually run thriving systems, not just sell products. Freshwater enthusiasts will find healthy live plants and fish as well, though the saltwater side clearly gets the spotlight. What sets Overboard Aquatics apart is the genuine investment Tyler and Bill make in each customer's success.
They'll quarantine fish for you, walk a complete beginner through their first tank setup, and even field questions over Facebook during a power outage. ' They won't sell you a fish just to make a sale — they make sure it's the right fit for your setup. Beyond aquatics, the store carries exotic animals including tarantulas, scorpions, turtles, and captive-bred millipedes, with transparent sourcing practices.
One customer was shown the parent animals and given free specialized substrate to ensure proper care. When someone called about their tortoise, staff took time to listen and offer real guidance. Prices are consistently praised as fair and competitive.
The atmosphere is clean, welcoming, and unpretentious. If you're in the tri-state area and care about the health of your aquatic animals, Overboard Aquatics delivers the kind of honest, knowledgeable service that big-box pet stores simply cannot match.
What they offer
Livestock, services, water
- Livestock & products
- Services
- Specializes in
Highlights
What makes them special
- Strong coral frag selection with reef-focused marine livestock
- Owners Tyler and Bill offer hands-on education for beginners and experienced hobbyists alike
- Quarantine services available for customer fish purchases
- Healthy live plants and freshwater fish alongside saltwater inventory
- Exotic animals including captive-bred invertebrates, tarantulas, and turtles
From keepers
Customer reviews
“Tyler and Bill are the best! Very knowledgeable and open to teaching. We couldn't reccomend them more!”
— Melissa Roberts5.0a week ago“I have bought multiple animals from them they have high standards for themselves and are the few people who will ethically own exotics and won't lie to their customers. I asked about a baby millipedes captive bred status as I was skeptical(because often people lie) but I was shown the parents and their set up. When I did not have Flake soil (an expensive soil) I was given a large deli cup FULL of it for free with my milli, they were also willing to hold the milli for me when I called in about him. I will support these guys anytime I need an animal.”
— BrookLynn DeRosa5.0a month ago“Great shop super knowledgeable about everything from the rainforest to the reef”
— Ben Adams5.0a month ago“Great Place!! Staff is excellent and super knowledgeable. They are always willing to help and LISTEN to you. They are great to chat with about all kinds of pets, bugs, reptiles, you name it. No reason to go anywhere else.”
— Tom Mc (Swamper Tom)5.0a month ago“Beautiful fishies and plants! My daughter and I have a terrific experience every time. We now have 2 beautiful, thriving aquariums thanks to their personable and knowledgeable team!”
— Jenna Keener5.03 months ago“A huge variety of fishes. Very knowledgeable about fishes and aquariums.”
— That’s 1zpy35.05 months ago“Bob is sooo kind and smart!! It's very clean and easy to shop. I found the prices to be fair! Not easy to find these days. You can see he really cares about his assorted friends! It's worth the drive from Hawley, pa!!!!”
— Terry Falcone5.06 months ago“Love this store everyone is super helpful, knowledgeable, and don’t yell at you for political views! Won’t be going anywhere else”
— Brett Tiger5.07 months ago“Super informative reasonably priced healthy plants and aquatic animals”
— Mel5.09 months ago“Amazing place to go to, the staff is fantastic and super knowledgeable, they will help in any way possible from what I have experienced so far! I'm already thinking about my second tank, and I know where I will be going to get it ready.!”
— A B5.011 months ago
Reference
Frequently asked questions
Note — Store information and services may change. Always call (845) 672-3559 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Overboard Aquatics.