About
Tucked into a compact storefront in Port Jervis, NY, Overboard Aquatics is the kind of local aquarium store regulars happily drive 40 minutes to reach, with some coming from as far as Hawley, Pennsylvania. Owners Tyler and Bill run it with a contagious passion for aquatic life, and customers consistently describe staff who are patient, deeply knowledgeable, and never in a hurry. As one recent visitor put it, "Tyler was very friendly and knowledgeable.
" The shop leans marine, with a rotating selection of coral frags and saltwater fish that pulls reef keepers from across Orange County and neighboring Pennsylvania. One hobbyist even picked up bio balls that had been seasoning in the store's own sump for two years to finish a reef cycle. Freshwater fishkeepers are well served too, with healthy live plants, community fish, and starter snails for sale in Port Jervis, NY.
If you are hunting saltwater fish or freshwater plants near me, the team will match livestock to your specific setup rather than just ring up a sale. Beyond the tanks, Overboard has become a destination for exotics: captive-bred invertebrates like tarantulas, scorpions, vinegaroons, roaches, and beetles, plus turtles, tortoises, anoles, and axolotls. Sourcing is transparent, and the staff happily field questions about everything from the rainforest to the reef.
They will quarantine fish for you, walk a first-timer through a complete tank setup, and even handle aquarium maintenance and tank moves. If something is not on the shelf, they will order it in for you. The atmosphere is clean, welcoming, and refreshingly unpretentious.
One shopper with social anxiety noted there are "no silly or dumb questions" here, and another loves how patiently Tyler answers her young son's endless questions about every animal in the shop. With fair prices and genuine care for every creature, Overboard Aquatics delivers the honest, hands-on service big-box stores cannot match.
What they offer
Fish & livestock for sale at Overboard Aquatics in Port Jervis, NY
Overboard Aquatics stocks corals, reef fish, invertebrates, axolotls, rare and hard-to-find species, aquarium plants and freshwater & saltwater fish for sale in Port Jervis, NY. As an aquarium store serving Port Jervis, NY, it also offers aquarium consultations, fish quarantine, water testing, aquarium setup and tank maintenance.
- Livestock & products
- Specializes in
Highlights
What makes them special
- Owners Tyler and Bill earn near-universal praise for patient, no-pressure, deeply knowledgeable guidance
- Marine-leaning selection of coral frags and saltwater fish draws reef keepers from across the tri-state area
- Healthy freshwater live plants, community fish, and starter snails for new aquarists
- Standout exotics: captive-bred invertebrates (tarantulas, scorpions, vinegaroons, beetles) plus turtles, anoles, and axolotls
- In-person services include tank setup, aquarium maintenance and tank moves, fish quarantine, and special orders
From keepers
Customer reviews
“Beautiful set up! The staff is great and knowledgeable. Always there to offer advice or a friendly word.”
— Janet Kumpf5.05 days ago“Overboard Aquatics and Exotics is a wonderful place for you and your family to find all your pet needs. If you have reptiles or birds, or anything that isn't a dog or cat--this is an awesome spot to visit. The staff is very friendly and caring, and if you're like me and experience social anxiety, they make you feel very welcome. There are no silly or dumb questions, ask anything you like and they do their best to answer. I really enjoy shopping here, and they are so reasonable. I highly recommend giving it a try. Don't pass it up”
— Sarah Freeman5.05 days ago“We had a great experience at this shop. Tyler was very friendly and knowledgeable. He answered all of our questions and we didn't feel rushed. We will definitely be returning customers!”
— Anonymous5.05 days ago“Not one of the biggest stores I've been to but has a pretty good variety and selection, they had everything I was looking for and when we were talking they said they could order anything they didn't have in store”
— Vincent Lorenzo5.05 days ago“Tyler and Bill are extremely knowledgeable of about every issue I’ve had with my animals. I recommend them highly for whatever your needs and wants are.”
— Sheri Russi5.05 days ago“First time visiting this business after reading all of the praise it received on here...my experience was nothing like others who chose to comment on here. Maybe the store was in the middle of a renovation or between fish deliveries but, as I walked down only short isle with few tanks holding very few fish, I failed to see the reason for the positive comments. Should I attempt a future visit, I'm hoping for a more positive experience.”
— Tony Iacona1.05 days ago“Solid advice, well cared for fish”
— Thomas Crary5.02 weeks ago“They sell nightcrawlers”
— Kevin O'Connell5.03 weeks ago“All the gentlemen here are very helpful and knowledgeable on all things fish , would definitely come back and recommend to others”
— Aiden Marie5.0a month ago“If you're looking for invertebrates, this place has the, and they have more than the usual tarantulas! Roaches, beetles, vinegaroons... highly recommend! Staff were happy to answer questions and store was well-maintained.”
— Northeast Bugs & Beasts5.0a month ago
Reference
Frequently asked questions
Note — Store information and services may change. Always call (845) 672-3559 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Overboard Aquatics.