Fishstores.org
StatesBest StoresServicesNear meMapToolsGuidesSpecies
Fishstores.org

The most comprehensive directory of brick-and-mortar fish stores in the United States.

Find Fish Stores

  • Fish Stores Near Me
  • Browse by State
  • Best by Specialty
  • Stores by Service
  • Nationwide Store Map

Care Guides

  • Freshwater fish & shrimp
  • Saltwater & reef
  • Tanks & equipment
  • Troubleshooting
  • Browse all guides →
  • Species directory →

Resources

  • About Us
  • Email Us
  • Sitemap
© 2026 fishstores.org. All rights reserved.
Privacy PolicyTerms of ServiceAccessibility
  1. Home
  2. ›
  3. Best
  4. ›
  5. Rare Species
  6. ›
  7. New York

Rare Species · New York

Best rare species fish stores in New York.

26 stores

26 stores specializing in rare, exotic, and hard-to-find fish species across New York. Ratings, hours, and directions for every shop.

Editor's pick

Highly rated specialists

Best-reviewed rare species shops in New York — every one of them keeper-vetted, not algorithmic.

Rated 4.5+
No. 01

Aquatic Haven

5.0
Fulton, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 02

Fluid Dynamics Aquarium Services and Store

5.0
Deer Park, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 03

City Island Aquarium Tropical Fish Sales

5.0
Bronx, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 04

Complete Aquarium

4.9
Bedford Hills, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 05

Underground Aquaticz

4.9
West Babylon, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 06

Overboard Aquatics

4.9
Port Jervis, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing

The full list

Every rare species store in New York

Sorted by rating — every verified specialist in the state.

26 stores
No. 01

Aquatic Haven

5.0
Fulton, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 02

Fluid Dynamics Aquarium Services and Store

5.0
Deer Park, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 03

City Island Aquarium Tropical Fish Sales

5.0
Bronx, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 04

Complete Aquarium

4.9
Bedford Hills, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 05

Underground Aquaticz

4.9
West Babylon, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 06

Overboard Aquatics

4.9
Port Jervis, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 07

PREDATORY FINS

4.8
Copiague, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 08

Reef Shark Aquarium Inc

4.8
East Meadow, NYSaltwaterVisit listing
No. 09

Buckley's Fish Room

4.7
Ballston Spa, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 10

TIA Collection Corals (Tropical Island Aquatics) Saltwater Only

4.7
Deer Park, NYSaltwaterVisit listing
No. 11

Michael's NYAquatic

4.7
Yonkers, NYSaltwaterVisit listing
No. 12

Aquarium Solutions 101

4.7
Wappingers Falls, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 13

Eddie's Aquarium Centre

4.6
Cohoes, NYFreshwater · Saltwater · PondVisit listing
No. 14

ABC Reefs

4.6
Solvay, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 15

Coral Sea Aquatics

4.6
Orchard Park, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 16

The Fish Place

4.6
North Tonawanda, NYFreshwater · Saltwater · BrackishVisit listing
No. 17

Tropical Showcase

4.5
Hicksville, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 18

Jawz Aquarium

4.5
Elmsford, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 19

Amazing Aquarium

4.5
Brooklyn, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 20

Country Critters Ltd

4.5
Patchogue, NYFreshwater · Saltwater · PondVisit listing
No. 21

Rockland Aquarium

4.4
Bardonia, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 22

Kissena Aquarium Inc

4.4
Flushing, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 23

Beital's Aquariums Sales, Services & Ponds

4.3
Pearl River, NYFreshwater · Saltwater · PondVisit listing
No. 24

Pete's Aquariums & Fish

4.2
Fishkill, NYFreshwater · Saltwater · PondVisit listing
No. 25

Monster Aquarium Inc - Shop in Queens New York

4.2
Flushing, NYFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 26

The Aquarium Shop Westbury

4.2
Westbury, NYFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing

By city

Deer Park2·Flushing2·Fulton1·Bronx1·Bedford Hills1·West Babylon1·Port Jervis1·Copiague1
View all fish stores in New York

More in New York

SaltwaterFreshwaterCoralLive PlantCichlidKoi & PondInvertebrate