About
Country Critters Ltd in Patchogue, New York is a sprawling pet emporium that has earned a devoted Long Island following over more than a decade. While the store carries everything from reptiles to rabbits, its aquatics department is the standout draw — one that has pulled hobbyists from as far as Ohio just to browse the tanks. The freshwater fish selection is particularly impressive, regularly stocking species that most local shops simply don't carry.
Reviewers specifically mention discus, pond fish, and harder-to-find varieties that border on rare. The saltwater side holds its own too, with reef tank enthusiasts praising the staff for their deep knowledge of coral care and balanced reef systems. One reef keeper noted that the team actually talked them out of unnecessary equipment and internet-fueled impulse purchases — prioritizing tank health over a sale.
That kind of integrity keeps people coming back. The store also stocks live plants and a solid range of supplies, from fish food to freeze-dried dog treats and everything in between. It functions as one of the few remaining independent animal feed distributors in the area with a genuinely vast selection.
Beyond the tanks, Country Critters has an atmosphere all its own. Ducks waddle through the aisles, a wallaby roams freely, and a resident bird whistles at customers from its perch. It's chaotic in the best way — the kind of place kids beg to visit and adults find hard to leave.
The store offers small pet boarding, a meaningful perk for rabbit and small mammal owners who struggle to find reliable care. Staff members like Jen and Brandon are called out by name in reviews for their expertise and warmth. The team is known for walking customers through tank setups, recommending proper food, and making sure new hobbyists leave confident rather than overwhelmed.
Some reviewers have noted occasional inconsistency in fish handling, but the overall consensus is clear: for freshwater variety, saltwater knowledge, and a genuinely unique shopping experience on Long Island, Country Critters delivers.
What they offer
Livestock, services, water
- Livestock & products
- Services
- Fish BoardingConsultation
- Specializes in
Highlights
What makes them special
- One of Long Island's top freshwater fish selections, regularly stocking rare and hard-to-find species
- Knowledgeable reef tank staff who prioritize healthy setups over unnecessary sales
- Unique family-friendly atmosphere with free-roaming ducks, a wallaby, and resident birds
- Small pet boarding services available on-site
- Discus, pond fish, corals, and live plants consistently in stock
From keepers
Customer reviews
“I purchased my chickens hay and crickets from here. It’s the best quality for the surrounding areas. I also purchase my dog’s food from here. They are one of the only animal feed distributors that have a vast selection. My dog eats regular small kibble with freeze dry meat in it and I buy their gravy packets.”
— R J5.02 hours ago“As a newbie, just over 1 year in the hobby this was my second visit and this place just doesn’t disappoint! Got there at 6:30 greeted by smiles and several helpful folks! They made me feel that they wouldn’t let me leave until they solved my issues! Thank you so much!!! Tank is almost set in place today!!!”
— Joe D5.0a week ago“I love this place. The fish section is really nice and ofc the land animals are very nice as well. Especially the wallaby that roams around. I do have a question tho. Kinda niche, but probably around 10 years ago you guys had some strange blue/black type bear thing in the back room and the light was always off so I couldn’t see it very well. It ALWAYS interested me and every time I think about this place I always think about that animal. There was a note on that window of the door that said it was being transferred to the holtsville ecology site I believe, for better care. But yea, it looked like a blueish bear and it was quite big. If the owner or anyone knows what I’m talking about and what kind of animal it was I would love a reply! Great place”
— Dom D5.0a week ago“Hard to compete with this pet store, especially as fish goes. I live in Ohio and while in town I HAD to stop here.”
— Shane Vasquez5.04 weeks ago“Hermoso”
— Juan Manuel Diaz Quero5.0a month ago“Great store, great selection and great prices!! Brandon is great!! Best for all your pet needs! Better than a chain for sure”
— MARTINO MASIELLO5.0Edited 2 months ago“Excellent service. Very friendly. Got the fish I wanted and the very helpful staff hooked me up with the proper food. Also asked about my current tank to make sure my fish would thrive. Highly recommend!”
— Amanda Steadman5.02 months ago“Terrible store. over priced the staff is also inexperienced and unwelcoming ive been Disappointed my last three visits to the store”
— Christopher Tavarez1.02 months ago“Good”
— Jafeth Cubas5.02 months ago“Very friendly staff and owner”
— Johnny Leon5.02 months ago
Reference
Frequently asked questions
Note — Store information and services may change. Always call (631) 758-6777 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Country Critters Ltd.