Country Critters Ltd

Country Critters Ltd in Patchogue, New York is a sprawling pet emporium that has earned a devoted Long Island following over more than a decade. While the store carries everything from reptiles to rabbits, its aquatics department is the standout draw — one that has pulled hobbyists from as far as Ohio just to browse the tanks. The freshwater fish selection is particularly impressive, regularly stocking species that most local shops simply don't carry.

Reviewers specifically mention discus, pond fish, and harder-to-find varieties that border on rare. The saltwater side holds its own too, with reef tank enthusiasts praising the staff for their deep knowledge of coral care and balanced reef systems. One reef keeper noted that the team actually talked them out of unnecessary equipment and internet-fueled impulse purchases — prioritizing tank health over a sale.

That kind of integrity keeps people coming back. The store also stocks live plants and a solid range of supplies, from fish food to freeze-dried dog treats and everything in between. It functions as one of the few remaining independent animal feed distributors in the area with a genuinely vast selection.

Beyond the tanks, Country Critters has an atmosphere all its own. Ducks waddle through the aisles, a wallaby roams freely, and a resident bird whistles at customers from its perch. It's chaotic in the best way — the kind of place kids beg to visit and adults find hard to leave.

The store offers small pet boarding, a meaningful perk for rabbit and small mammal owners who struggle to find reliable care. Staff members like Jen and Brandon are called out by name in reviews for their expertise and warmth. The team is known for walking customers through tank setups, recommending proper food, and making sure new hobbyists leave confident rather than overwhelmed.

Some reviewers have noted occasional inconsistency in fish handling, but the overall consensus is clear: for freshwater variety, saltwater knowledge, and a genuinely unique shopping experience on Long Island, Country Critters delivers.