Buffalo Pet Supply

Buffalo Pet Supply in Tonawanda, New York is a family-owned shop that has built a loyal following across the greater Buffalo area for its impressive breadth of live animals and the genuine care that owners Dave and Stephanie pour into the operation. While the store covers everything from dogs and cats to reptiles and rodents, the aquarium section stands out — reviewers rave about a freshwater fish selection that includes species they've never encountered elsewhere, along with healthy livestock and competitively priced aquarium supplies. One customer called it flatly the best place for aquarium supplies, and another described checking every box during a fish-buying visit, from attentive service to stunning stock.

The reptile side of the business is equally strong. The store is a go-to source for crested gecko diet, enclosure setups, meal worms, live insects, and feeder animals — multiple snake and gecko owners say the quality of live feed here far surpasses big-box alternatives like PetSmart. Dart frog enthusiasts, gargoyle gecko keepers, and white tree frog owners all report finding exactly what they need, plus expert guidance on habitat construction and care.

The shop even stocks isopods and other clean-up crews, a detail that signals serious hobbyist credibility. What comes through most clearly in hundreds of reviews is the staff's depth of knowledge. Employees like Mari and Elijah take time to investigate customer questions and make thoughtful product suggestions rather than just pushing the most expensive option.

Several reviewers note that staff will recommend a cheaper product if it's the right one for the animal — a refreshing approach that builds trust. The animal habitats inside the store itself reflect this philosophy: no overcrowding, proper lighting, compatible species, and visible enrichment items. The store carries Fromm dog food at competitive prices and will even special-order animals like fancy rats from their breeder network.

With accessible hours for people working various shifts and a spacious, well-organized layout, Buffalo Pet Supply rewards the visit whether you're picking up crickets or planning an entire aquarium build.