Fishstores.org
StatesBest StoresServicesNear meMapToolsGuidesSpecies
Fishstores.org

The most comprehensive directory of brick-and-mortar fish stores in the United States.

Find Fish Stores

  • Fish Stores Near Me
  • Browse by State
  • Best by Specialty
  • Stores by Service
  • Nationwide Store Map

Care Guides

  • Freshwater fish & shrimp
  • Saltwater & reef
  • Tanks & equipment
  • Troubleshooting
  • Browse all guides →
  • Species directory →

Resources

  • About Us
  • Email Us
  • Sitemap
© 2026 fishstores.org. All rights reserved.
Privacy PolicyTerms of ServiceAccessibility
  1. Home
  2. ›
  3. Best
  4. ›
  5. Rare Species
  6. ›
  7. New Jersey

Rare Species · New Jersey

Best rare species fish stores in New Jersey.

17 stores

17 stores specializing in rare, exotic, and hard-to-find fish species across New Jersey. Ratings, hours, and directions for every shop.

Editor's pick

Highly rated specialists

Best-reviewed rare species shops in New Jersey — every one of them keeper-vetted, not algorithmic.

Rated 4.5+
No. 01

PicKFish Pets

4.9
Kenilworth, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 02

Global Fish Co.

4.9
Elmwood Park, NJFreshwater · PondVisit listing
No. 03

Beni Hanna Nishikigoi, LLC

4.9
Penns Grove, NJPondVisit listing
No. 04

J B Tropical Fish

4.8
Williamstown, NJFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 05

Discus Madness Inc. Showroom open to the public.

4.8
Union, NJFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 06

Absolutely Fish

4.7
Clifton, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing

The full list

Every rare species store in New Jersey

Sorted by rating — every verified specialist in the state.

17 stores
No. 01

PicKFish Pets

4.9
Kenilworth, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 02

Global Fish Co.

4.9
Elmwood Park, NJFreshwater · PondVisit listing
No. 03

Beni Hanna Nishikigoi, LLC

4.9
Penns Grove, NJPondVisit listing
No. 04

J B Tropical Fish

4.8
Williamstown, NJFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 05

Discus Madness Inc. Showroom open to the public.

4.8
Union, NJFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 06

Absolutely Fish

4.7
Clifton, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 07

Exotic Aquatics

4.7
Washington, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 08

Jersey Corals

4.7
Paterson, NJSaltwaterVisit listing
No. 09

Sea Level Aquarium

4.6
Pine Brook, NJSaltwater · FreshwaterVisit listing
No. 10

Ely's Tropical Fish

4.6
Florham Park, NJFreshwater · Saltwater · PondVisit listing
No. 11

PetCenter

4.6
Old Bridge, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 12

Aquariums By JJ

4.4
Bloomingdale, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 13

Ocean Gallery

4.4
North Plainfield, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 14

88 Pet World

4.2
Brick Township, NJFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 15

AquaScapeOnline

4.1
Belleville, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 16

Adam's Pet Safari

4.0
Chester, NJFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 17

Aquarium Paradise

3.8
Belleville, NJFreshwaterVisit listing

By city

Belleville2·Kenilworth1·Elmwood Park1·Penns Grove1·Williamstown1·Union1·Clifton1·Washington1
View all fish stores in New Jersey

More in New Jersey

SaltwaterFreshwaterCoralLive PlantCichlidKoi & PondInvertebrate