Fishstores.org
StatesMapSearchNear meToolsGuidesSpecies
Fishstores.org

The most comprehensive directory of brick-and-mortar fish stores in the United States.

Find Fish Stores

  • Fish Stores Near Me
  • Browse by State
  • Nationwide Store Map

Care Guides

  • Freshwater fish & shrimp
  • Saltwater & reef
  • Tanks & equipment
  • Troubleshooting
  • Browse all guides →
  • Species directory →

Resources

  • About Us
  • Email Us
  • Sitemap
© 2026 fishstores.org. All rights reserved.
Privacy PolicyTerms of ServiceAccessibility
  1. Home
  2. ›
  3. Best
  4. ›
  5. Rare Species
  6. ›
  7. New Jersey

Rare Species · New Jersey

Best rare species fish stores in New Jersey.

13 stores

13 stores specializing in rare, exotic, and hard-to-find fish species across New Jersey. Ratings, hours, and directions for every shop.

Editor's pick

Highly rated specialists

Best-reviewed rare species shops in New Jersey — every one of them keeper-vetted, not algorithmic.

Rated 4.5+
No. 01

PicKFish Pets

5.0
Kenilworth, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 02

J B Tropical Fish

4.8
Williamstown, NJFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 03

Global Fish Co.

4.8
Elmwood Park, NJFreshwater · PondVisit listing
No. 04

Beni Hanna Nishikigoi, LLC

4.8
Penns Grove, NJPondVisit listing
No. 05

Absolutely Fish

4.7
Clifton, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 06

Exotic Aquatics

4.7
Washington, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing

The full list

Every rare species store in New Jersey

Sorted by rating — every verified specialist in the state.

13 stores
No. 01

PicKFish Pets

5.0
Kenilworth, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 02

J B Tropical Fish

4.8
Williamstown, NJFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 03

Global Fish Co.

4.8
Elmwood Park, NJFreshwater · PondVisit listing
No. 04

Beni Hanna Nishikigoi, LLC

4.8
Penns Grove, NJPondVisit listing
No. 05

Absolutely Fish

4.7
Clifton, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 06

Exotic Aquatics

4.7
Washington, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 07

Ely's Tropical Fish

4.6
Florham Park, NJFreshwater · Saltwater · PondVisit listing
No. 08

Jersey Corals

4.6
Paterson, NJSaltwaterVisit listing
No. 09

PetCenter

4.6
Old Bridge, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 10

Aquariums By JJ

4.5
Bloomingdale, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 11

Ocean Gallery

4.4
North Plainfield, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 12

AquaScapeOnline

4.1
Belleville, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 13

Aquarium Paradise

3.9
Belleville, NJFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing

By city

Belleville2·Kenilworth1·Williamstown1·Elmwood Park1·Penns Grove1·Clifton1·Washington1·Florham Park1
View all fish stores in New Jersey

More in New Jersey

SaltwaterFreshwaterCoralLive PlantCichlidKoi & PondInvertebrate