Tucked away in Penns Grove, New Jersey, Beni Hanna Nishikigoi is a dedicated koi breeding farm run by Matt McCann and Jennifer — a husband-and-wife team whose passion for nishikigoi runs deep. This isn't a typical pet store with tanks lining the walls; it's a working koi farm where visitors walk the grounds, hand-select their fish from a massive inventory, and leave with American-bred koi and Japanese imports that range from affordable pond additions to show-quality specimens with striking patterns and colors. Matt's expertise in koi genetics and breeding is what sets this operation apart.
He takes an outside-the-box approach to developing unique color patterns and varieties, blending science with artistry in ways that have earned him invitations to speak at pond clubs as far as Atlanta. His presentation to the Atlanta Koi Club on koi genetics drew praise for its depth and clarity. Reviewers consistently note his commitment to proper quarantine practices and fish health — one longtime customer has been traveling from Florida for nearly 20 years to buy from them.
Jennifer handles customer communication with impressive responsiveness, sending videos of available fish within minutes and arranging curbside pickup when needed. Together, they've cultivated a reputation that draws pond enthusiasts from Pennsylvania, Georgia, and beyond — many driving two hours or more and calling it completely worth the trip. The farm experience itself is part of the appeal.
Customers browse the facility, learn about the breeding process firsthand, and pick out individual koi themselves. Several reviewers mention being blown away by the setup and the sheer selection available. Plants are also on hand for pond keepers looking to complete their water gardens.
Beni Hanna actively supports local pond clubs and the broader koi community through education and outreach. Matt's knowledge extends beyond fish into pond design and filtration, making this a genuine one-stop consultation resource for anyone building or maintaining a koi pond. Prices are consistently described as reasonable for the quality offered.
Rhonda E
11 reviews
We recently had the pleasure of hosting Matt McCann of Beni Hana Nishikigoi at our residence in Marietta, GA, where he graciously came to educate the members of the Atlanta Koi Club and showcase many of the beautiful koi he and his team have bred for sale. Matt’s presentation on koi genetics was not only incredibly informative but also delivered with enthusiasm and clarity. His personable demeanor, exceptional knowledge, and genuine love for koi truly stood out. We were especially impressed by his commitment to proper quarantining practices and his thoughtful recommendations for maintaining koi health. His expertise in breeding and outside-the-box approach to developing unique patterns, colors, and varieties demonstrate a remarkable blend of science and artistry. Matt’s passion and professionalism make him a tremendous asset to the koi community. We are truly grateful for the time and care he shared with our club. Attached are pics of the two koi we chose this day as additions to our pond.
Asia Lewis
2 reviews
We've gotten 4 koi's from Jennifer so far - they are lovely fish. Jennifer is very knowledgable & so sweet to us each time we go. We will absoutely be seeing her at the farm in the spring for more koi's. :)
James Ragghianti
2 reviews
This is an awesome, professional koi breeding farm, the only one I will go to for my koi. The selection is incredible, the owners are extremely helpful and friendly and the prices are great. I have purchased many koi at Beni Hanna and never quarantine them, they are all in great shape. It is a fun experience every time. I highly recommend Beni Hanna Nishikigoi koi farm.
Vin Rudi
28 reviews
Matt, Jenifer and the family are the go to for Koi! I was buying from online suppliers , NO MORE! Beni Hanna Nishikigoi is now my go too for our Koi, won't be going anywhere else. Huge inventory and all price ranges of beautiful Koi! Check them out!
Emmy Shapard
3 reviews
Great Koi farm Matt and Jenn are legit and know what they are doing ! Koi are beautiful!
Joe Thuet
7 reviews
My family and I had an awesome visit today. The owners were so kind to take their time with us on this very hot day. We bought 2 for my parents. Keep up the awesome work… we will be back!
Diane Herder
4 reviews
I visited Matt and Jen on May 3rd. I purchased four fish. One was a beautiful white silvery Japanese Koi. Matt was very knowledgeable and I learned a lot about their breeding process. Thanks again for all the information.
Tim Farrell
9 reviews
Jennifer and Matt were a pleasure to deal with. The selection there was mind blowing … and I was able to select each koi myself. The prices are reasonable for such high quality and beautiful koi.
Tatyana eades
4 reviews
They were extremely nice and knowledgeable. I was blown away by the setup and availability of fish and plants. Definitely plan to return in the future!
Teresa Enck
2 reviews
What a great experience we had! We live in Pennsylvania about an hour and a half away from them so before we decided to drive there, we contacted them to see if they had the type of fish we were looking for. Jennifer sent us videos within minutes. She and Matt were so helpful and knowledgeable, we made the trip there and found what we were looking for! Great place, quality Koi and reasonable prices! We would highly recommend!
Note: Store information and services may change. Always call (609) 420-0434 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Beni Hanna Nishikigoi, LLC.
Phone
(609) 420-0434Website
www.benihannanishikigoi.com/Address
67 N Stumpy Rd, Carneys Point, NJ 08069, USA, Penns Grove, NJ
Take control of your listing to update info and respond to reviews.
Claim This ListingFind on Map
67 N Stumpy Rd, Carneys Point, NJ 08069, USA
February 7, 2026
Verified Data
Information verified through Google Places API and community contributions.
Other aquarium shops nearby worth checking out