About
Exotic Jungle Pet Supply has been a Morgantown institution for roughly 40 years, operating as the kind of sprawling, eclectic pet store that big-box chains simply can't replicate. Walk through the door and you'll find yourself in a space that feels more like a menagerie than a retail shop — tortoises roaming the floor, birds perched in the open, cats lounging between aisles, and room after room of animals and supplies stretching deeper than you'd expect. The fish department draws hobbyists from across the region, with some customers driving nearly an hour for species they can't find elsewhere.
Freshwater enthusiasts will find a solid cichlid selection — including decent-sized specimens — along with bettas, albino plecos, and electric blue rams. One reviewer specifically praised their feeder fish as the best around at fair prices. The store positions itself as the place to go for "fancier fish the big box stores don't have," and the breadth of their livestock generally backs that up.
Staff interactions skew positive — multiple reviewers describe being greeted immediately, having questions answered patiently, and receiving genuine guidance on animal care and supplies. The turtle adoption story stands out: one family called ten different stores and found Exotic Jungle to be the only one that took time to ensure they had the right setup before sending an animal home. The owner has a loyal following and is frequently mentioned as approachable and passionate.
Transparency demands noting that a significant minority of reviews raise serious concerns about animal health and tank cleanliness. Some customers have reported sick fish, dirty enclosures, and declining conditions in the reptile and resident animal areas. These criticisms are worth weighing against the store's long history and large base of satisfied regulars.
For Morgantown-area fishkeepers, Exotic Jungle remains the primary local alternative to chain stores, offering harder-to-find freshwater species, competitive pricing on feeders and insects, and the kind of personal service that comes from a family-run operation with deep roots in the community.
What they offer
Livestock, services, water
- Livestock & products
- Services
- Consultation
- Specializes in
Highlights
What makes them special
- 40-year Morgantown institution with sprawling selection
- Freshwater fish including cichlids, electric blue rams, bettas, and plecos
- Best feeder fish pricing in the area according to regulars
- Species not available at big-box chain stores
- Hands-on owner and staff known for personalized animal care guidance
From keepers
Customer reviews
“This place is pathetic.”
— Sophie Bunnyy1.06 days ago“My wife said that this is her new favorite pet supply. One of the best she has ever been to. I'm afraid of how much money she is going to spend here. Took the kids with her and the talked about it all night. She met the owner and told me she was really cool. 10 out of 10.”
— Rick Walsh5.0a week ago“Truly fabulous experience. I had messaged the owner about what I was looking for, service was friendly and excellent. When we went in we were thrilled to see such a wonderful selection. I absolutely recommend checking them out, you’ll surely find something you enjoy.”
— Michaela Lentz5.0a week ago“Great service, friendly knowledgeable staff. Highly recommend shopping here.”
— Reno Scotchel5.02 weeks ago“No tiger no service”
— Brendon Mann1.0a month ago“Usually have what I'm looking for....”
— William G Beckwith4.02 months ago“Lots of options to choose from for all different kinds of pets. Friendly and helpful staff that offer assistance every time I visit.”
— Leah Duncan5.03 months ago“Our family is very pleased to have call this pet store! I truly love how they made sure we was ready to welcome our baby turtle into our home from supplies we truly needed and thing we didn’t need. Seeing how truly they care about their animals and the forever homes. You could tell these animals are care for. Don’t get me wrong I called 10 different stores and none of them took the time like they did was always help to answers any questions. 10/10 Highly recommend the best store to help welcome your new forever pet into your home”
— Jordana Yeager5.04 months ago“They are so great. Very helpful very clean. Love this place”
— Hannah Ladner5.05 months ago“Best feeder fish around at a nice price.”
— Anna Hovatter5.06 months ago
Reference
Frequently asked questions
Note — Store information and services may change. Always call (304) 296-8552 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Exotic Jungle Pet Supply.