Fishstores.org
  • Tools
  • States
  • Map
  • Near Me
  • Search
fishstores.org

The most comprehensive directory of brick-and-mortar fish stores in the United States.

Find Fish Stores

  • Fish Stores Near Me
  • Browse by State
  • Nationwide Store Map

Resources

  • About Us
  • Email Us
  • Sitemap
© 2025 fishstores.org. All rights reserved.
Privacy PolicyTerms of ServiceAccessibility
  1. States
  2. New York
  3. Tonawanda
  4. Buffalo Pet Supply

Buffalo Pet Supply

1345 Military Rd, Tonawanda, NY 14217, USA
Highly Rated
4.6(610 reviews)
Closed• 11AM-7PM
unknown
Call (716) 874-1951Get DirectionsVisit Website
Buffalo Pet Supply is a premier destination for pet lovers, renowned for its exceptional customer service and extensive knowledge across a variety of pets. Owned by the dynamic duo, Dave and Stephanie, the store offers personalized service and a diverse range of products, making it the perfect spot for pet owners seeking quality supplies and expert advice. Whether you're in need of essentials for your Pitbull or fancy rats, Buffalo Pet Supply guarantees satisfaction with its tailored offerings.

Loading map...

View on Google Maps
Store Photos10 photos
Buffalo Pet Supply - Main photo
Click to view full size
Buffalo Pet Supply - Photo 2
Buffalo Pet Supply - Photo 3
Buffalo Pet Supply - Photo 4
Hours & Contact

Store Hours

Monday:11AM-7PM
Tuesday:11AM-7PM
Wednesday:11AM-7PM
Thursday:11AM-7PM
Friday:11AM-7PM
Saturday:11AM-7PM
Sunday:11AM-6PM

Contact Information

Phone

(716) 874-1951

Website

buffalopetsupply.com/

Address

1345 Military Rd, Tonawanda, NY 14217, USA

Customer Reviews
4.6(610)

Vincent Rico

Love this place. They are always helpful and know what there talking about and show you options even if it’s cheaper in price because they care more about helping your and your animals stay healthy then they are about money. Highly recommend for fish and reptiles and everything needed for them. They helped me get my whole setup for my day geckos and educated me and teach me more every time I go there

Sally Rutter

I would also like to thank the owners Dave and Stephanie. They are the nicest, knowledgeable, and the most patient people there go above and beyond (10 ⭐️ service and selection). They were a huge help with information on construction, care for the frogs and much more. They have the best service and prices in the county. Thanks again guys.😊💕

Clouts Sprouts

Absolutely! One of the best experiences I've ever had going to purchase a fish. These guys checked all of the boxes. They were attentive to the customers. The stock was amazing. They were fish that I never even saw before and I've seen my fair share of fish would definitely recommend to all of my friends if you have any questions and or concerns related to your aquarium. The Buffalo pet supply has got you covered from your new aquatic family members all the way down to the different items that they will need to maintain a healthy balanced lifestyle only found at Buffalo pet supply

Sandra Sungoddess

Best thing about this newly managed business is that they are always staffed! I They’ve got a great deal of lot’s of inventory of reptiles and fish and animals and rodents. seem to be a bit pricey.

Adeline W

I purchased three male gerbils here a few months ago. Very healthy, I haven’t had any health nor territorial issues so far. The establishment was clean and their cage was a perfect size and bedding depth for the species. I have not been able to socialize them beyond simple back touches, but that’s not a fault of the pet store. Sometimes desert rodents just dislike humans. 😅

Own this business?

Take control of your listing to update info and respond to reviews.

Claim This Listing
About This Store

Store with pet supplies including a range of fish and live animals such as reptiles and small mammals, plus knowledgeable staff.

Information Updated

July 26, 2025

Verified Data

Information verified through Google Places API and community contributions.