About
Whitlyn Aquatics is an independent aquarium store in Evansville, IN, tucked out by the airport and well worth the drive for hobbyists across the Tristate area. Regulars talk about spending two or three hours just taking it all in, and it's easy to see why: the shop runs the full range from nano tanks to a stocked, full-size koi pond right inside the store, with freshwater fish, saltwater fish, corals, invertebrates, and aquatic plants all out in the open. The coral selection is the heart of the place.
Whitlyn grows much of its own coral in-store, and the WYSIWYG frags — soft corals, colorful zoanthids, torch corals, and toadstools — are a major draw for reefers shopping for coral for sale in Evansville, IN. The Monday-night live coral auctions have become a community fixture, streamed with color-accurate video so bidders see exactly what they're getting. Some longtime customers say they've been shopping here since the doors opened, a few for nearly eight years.
On the freshwater side, you'll find healthy community fish and a growing aquatic-plant selection, complemented by a newer house-plant area that regulars have noticed and loved. Invertebrates round things out, from nerite and mystery snails to starfish. One visitor came in puzzling over a sluggish mystery snail and left with a plan — a green bean did the trick.
That hands-on guidance is the recurring theme in reviews: staff like Mitch and Evan, plus a friendly crew at the counter, take real time to teach customers about water health and stocking. Practical extras keep people coming back: in-store water testing, a quarantine program for incoming fish, a rewards program, and specialty equipment priced to compete. For anyone in southern Indiana hunting for koi, corals, or saltwater and freshwater fish available in Evansville, IN, Whitlyn Aquatics pairs an unusually deep, hands-on selection with a team that clearly loves the hobby.
What they offer
Fish & livestock for sale at Whitlyn Aquatics, LLC in Evansville, IN
Whitlyn Aquatics, LLC stocks corals, reef fish, invertebrates, koi, aquarium plants and freshwater, saltwater & pond fish for sale in Evansville, IN. As an aquarium store serving Evansville, IN, it also carries dry goods and aquarium equipment and offers fish quarantine, aquarium consultations and water testing.
- Livestock & products
- Services
- Specializes in
Highlights
What makes them special
- In-store coral propagation with WYSIWYG soft corals, zoanthids, and torch frags
- Monday-night live coral auctions streamed with color-accurate video
- Full stocked koi pond inside the store, spanning nano tanks to pond setups
- Knowledgeable, hands-on staff (Mitch, Evan) with in-store water testing and a quarantine program
- Freshwater and saltwater fish, aquatic plants, and invertebrates for sale in Evansville, IN
From keepers
Customer reviews
“Whitlyn Aquatics has become my go-to for coral. The auction setup keeps prices competitive and the selection is solid, but what really sets them apart is the staff — knowledgeable and genuinely helpful. Great place to shop whether you're new to the hobby or a seasoned reefer”
— Chris Alvey5.05 days ago“They have such a beautiful selection of fish but also plants. I tried to buy a plant and stood there waiting for someone to check me out for atleast 10 mins. I called the store hoping someone would come up front to answer the phone. I had to leave because I was on a tight schedule.”
— Kayla Rodenberg3.03 weeks ago“Just got my 3rd order from WA abd decided it's time to write a review. Every coral I've purchased from them has survived and thrived; as well as looking just as awesome in person as they do online. I don't even have fancy lights! Ive also ordered multiple freshwater fish and saltwater fish from them. Always healthy, sometimes even healthier than fish I buy locally (which is impressive for a fish sitting in a bag overnight) They also package the corals very well. I receive them in specimen cups and they are attached to foam to prevent them from getting knocked around in transit.”
— Lauren5.03 weeks ago“I bought an aquarium water master test kit from here. The lady at the counter was very kind and helpful. Great store, I'll be a returning customer!”
— AJ5.03 weeks ago“Always a fun and great experience during auctions!”
— Alyssa Cote5.03 weeks ago“After multiple emails and attempts to purchase, I have yet in three years to ever receive a response. There are way to many vendors who look forward to business not ignore it.”
— Peter Showalter1.0a month ago“Was the best place, however you gotta watch what you get, Just pay attention definitely not trying to talk bad about the place so won't be showing pictures which I have a few,”
— Steven Hite2.0Edited a month ago“They are very knowledgeable and friendly never had any issue with any plant or fish I have ever gotten from them best place to get fish in the area by far”
— Subaru975.0a month ago“They are very knowledgeable and friendly never had any issue with any plant or fish I have ever gotten from them best place to get fish in the area by far”
— Alex Allen5.0a month ago“this is no ordinary pet store. this place is incredible, and you could make a trip here that would be better than most zoos. saltwater, freshwater, from nanoscale to pond, they have it all covered. specialty equipment at better than amazon prices. they also grow their own coral in store. and they have a full in store koi pond as well, stocked with a wide variety at way better prices than you will find online, and without the wait and worry and stress on the fish. i spend like 2-3 hours there everytime i go just to get a look at everything. truly unique. don't miss it!”
— Fom Tooley (Fom Tooley, LLC)5.0a month ago
Reference
Frequently asked questions
Note — Store information and services may change. Always call (812) 402-0600 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Whitlyn Aquatics, LLC.