Seedy Sally's in Pendleton, Indiana isn't a fish store — it's something arguably rarer: a genuinely beloved neighborhood pet supply shop with an owner who treats every customer like family. Tucked behind the businesses fronting Route 67 on the Huntsville side of town, this unassuming storefront is run by Scott Anderson, a soft-spoken, deeply knowledgeable proprietor whose old-school customer service has earned an almost perfect rating from a fiercely loyal customer base. The store's roots are in bird and wild bird supplies — the name "Seedy Sally's" is a nod to its strength in seed and feed.
Scott is widely regarded as a bird expert, stocking a wide array of birdseed varieties, hummingbird feeders (American-made, with warranties), and large bags of peanuts that customers say they can't find anywhere else. But the shop has grown well beyond its avian origins into a full-service pet supply destination carrying premium, whole-ingredient dog and cat foods — the kind of specialty and breeder-recommended brands that vanish from big box shelves. Multiple reviewers describe Scott tracking down hard-to-find foods, contacting manufacturers on a customer's behalf, and even making shelf space for a particular large-bag size so a customer could save money buying in bulk.
The atmosphere is personal and warm. Scott remembers names — yours and your pets'. He carries purchases to your car.
He'll spend weeks helping you troubleshoot a picky eater. The shop also serves as a foster care and adoption location for animals, and has donated generously to local charities like Ernie's Heart. One practical note: Seedy Sally's is cash or check only — no credit cards accepted.
It's a small trade-off for the kind of attentive, individualized service that most people assumed disappeared decades ago. If you're in the Pendleton area and care about what you feed your pets and the birds in your backyard, Scott Anderson's little shop is absolutely worth seeking out.
Falon Medley
5 reviews
The most wonderful local pet shop! The owner goes above and beyond, always offering to take my items to the car for me and remembers mine and my dogs' names!
Tom Steiner
51 reviews
I have a dog who is a very picky eater. It has been a challenge to find food she will eat. I have tried different foods and she will eat it once or twice and not want it anymore. Scott has spent 3 weeks helping me find something she will eat. We went over the different reasons why she won't eat the food and discussed the different options available. He provided me with samples, suggestions and ideas on how to find something Georgia will eat. Soft spoken, friendly and concerned, you couldn't ask for a more helpful person to help you with your pet's needs.
Racheal Curts
129 reviews
Great service, fast friendly and will be back for all our seed and feed needs!
Steve Wilson
19 reviews
Your personal animal specialist! He remembers your name, and your preferences!
Mindy Hawkins
12 reviews
I fully intend to make this the only place I shop for my animals from here on out!!
Clete Ussq
19 reviews
The only place I know that has large bags of peanuts. Scott is a great guy and will bend over backwards to assist you in your needs. If I could I would give Seedy Sally 10 stars.
Susie Turk
55 reviews
total hometown service. This is the place to get your pet needs and wildlife seeds. Scott will even take it to your car. Always a pleasant attitude and great environment.
Trust Is Earned (Bebetter)
12 reviews
Scott is absolutely fantastic. He is easily one of the friendliest and most selfless business owners I’ve ever met. As long as Seedy Sally’s exists, Scott will have our business.
Mack Buck
37 reviews
How friendly the owner is brought me into this nice little shop. It's kind of a tucked away gem in a shopping center. He was nice enough to allow my dog inside to get his treats when he couldve just said no. The owner of the shop even helped me pick out the treats. My dog behaved very well with the cats and the whole experience was excellent. This will be my go to place for dog treats now. I wish I could give more than 5 stars.
Brent Brockley
46 reviews
Scott is one of the most kind and considerate people you will ever meet. His knowledge of pets, their supplies and their care, is expansive.
Note: Store information and services may change. Always call (765) 778-7347 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Seedy Sally's.
Take control of your listing to update info and respond to reviews.
Claim This ListingFind on Map
6869 S State Rd 67, Pendleton, IN 46064
February 7, 2026
Verified Data
Information verified through Google Places API and community contributions.
Other aquarium shops nearby worth checking out