Tucked away in Forked River, New Jersey, Lacey Pet Supply with Next Level Exotics has quietly built a devoted following among Ocean County's aquarium hobbyists and pet owners alike. Owned and operated by Dan and Colleen and their family, this shop punches well above its weight — a compact space packed with an impressive selection of both saltwater and freshwater fish, corals, live plants, and a full reptile section that includes everything from red tail boas to tegus to red eye tree frogs. The saltwater side is a particular draw.
Multiple reviewers cite it as their go-to marine aquarium source on the Jersey Shore, with healthy clownfish (including orange storm pairs), live rock, and the supplies needed to maintain a reef system. Dan's deep knowledge of water chemistry and tank cycling has guided many first-time saltwater keepers through setup and stocking. On the freshwater side, customers report strong tropical fish variety alongside koi and snails, with plants available for planted tank enthusiasts.
What sets Lacey Pet apart is the hands-on, genuinely personal service. Dan and his staff have been known to physically help a customer fit a replacement glass top on their tank, special-order a chinchilla and care for it until pickup day, or spend extended time walking a new fish keeper through every stage of their first family aquarium. Staff members like Landon are consistently called out by name for their attentiveness and product knowledge.
The store extends well beyond fish — reptiles, birds, small mammals like chinchillas and bunnies, feeders, dog treats, and supplies for chickens and cockatiels all share shelf space. Prices are consistently described as fair, and the shop is notably clean with healthy, well-maintained animals throughout. For anyone in the Forked River or greater Ocean County area looking for a real aquarium and exotic pet shop with substance behind the counter, Lacey Pet Supply delivers the kind of care and expertise that chain stores simply cannot replicate.
Austin Bunker
6 reviews
Actually has living bugs unlike most pet stores
Susan Kramer-Mills
13 reviews
Very clean and expert staff
Peter Cole
16 reviews
These guys are Fantastic...I moved to the NJ Shore several years ago from North NJ and had really missed the Hobby stores in North NJ etc. I discovered this store several months ago and was very happy to find them. They offer a very good selection of both salt and freshwater aquarium fish, supplies, foods, and equipment. Dan and staff are extremely knowledgeable and helpful. They have become my "GO TO" for all of my marine aquarium needs. They are, in my opinion, the best aquarium fish store on the NJ Shore area, I highly recommend them to beginners through advanced aquarists.
Mike S
5 reviews
Just bought my first red tail boa from here and they were nothing but professional and helpful, let Me see the snake and made sure I was comfortable and the right person before just trying to sell me it also very knowledgeable they truly care about the customer and the animals and I highly recommend them !!
cole luterek
7 reviews
A good locally owned pet store, with friendly helpful staff. I did have one bad experience in the past but staff was quick to resolve it. Would recommend to anyone looking for a nice clean pet store that takes care of their animals.
Charity Jo
2 reviews
A amazing pet store and he hade cute bunnies and very healthy pets it amazing. I’m letting you now if you need to buy a pet it’s amazing and the food for the pets especially for your children
Arlene Penate
3 reviews
My name is Arlene,today I went to the store to pick up a part I needed for my fish tank.I took the glass top that needed the part to see if it would work. Upon looking at it I knew I wouldn't be able to fix it. Dan and his wife took time out to help me put it on. They were great!! It's not to many merchants that would take time out to help. Thank you so much
Matt Mason
5 reviews
I hadn’t been into Lacey Pets in a few years, but I stopped by recently and was really impressed. The staff was super friendly and helpful, and Landon checked me out — he was awesome, quick, and knowledgeable. They really helped me with my turtle, Sunflower, and I couldn’t be more grateful for the care and attention she received. I grew up in the area, and it’s great to see a local pet shop still providing such great service. Highly recommend!
Mark Mccormick
21 reviews
Kinda puts all other pet stores to shame . Absolutely beautiful inside.
Christine Jackson
136 reviews
Staff is knowledgeable and quite helpful. I would highly recommend them.
Note: Store information and services may change. Always call (609) 971-7037 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Lacey Pet Supply with Next Level Exotics.
Take control of your listing to update info and respond to reviews.
Claim This ListingFind on Map
441 Lacey Rd, Forked River, NJ 08731, USA
February 7, 2026
Verified Data
Information verified through Google Places API and community contributions.
Other aquarium shops nearby worth checking out