About
First Choice Aquatics in Flemington, New Jersey, has built a loyal following among reef hobbyists for one clear reason: the corals are exceptional. " This is a coral-first shop, and owner Randy has leaned into that identity with obvious passion, even hosting the annual NJ Coral Show at the Elkwood Lodge to bring the local reefing community together. The store recently moved to a new, larger location, and regulars have noticed the upgrade.
Tanks are cleaner, the layout more organized, and the coral selection has expanded significantly. One customer running 370 gallons across three reef tanks called the new space a major step up and committed to making it their regular stop. Display tanks throughout the shop showcase what's possible, and Randy is known for helping customers scape and stock their setups — one reviewer credited him with helping design seven tanks and counting.
Beyond corals, First Choice Aquatics carries saltwater fish, freshwater fish, and live plants, though the saltwater side clearly gets the most attention and inventory. Dry goods cover the essentials — testing supplies, dosing equipment, frozen food, and pods — without venturing into deep discount territory. This isn't a budget shop; prices run higher than average, but multiple reviewers note the livestock quality justifies the cost, with zoanthids and fish thriving long-term after purchase.
Staff members like Jesi and Justin earn consistent praise for genuine helpfulness. Jesi once walked a customer through a saltwater issue over the phone with no purchase involved — the kind of service that builds trust. Randy also runs a tank maintenance program, transforming at least one longtime hobbyist's 55-gallon saltwater setup from a constant struggle into a stable, thriving system.
For reef keepers in central New Jersey willing to invest in premium coral and knowledgeable guidance, First Choice Aquatics delivers where it counts.
What they offer
Fish & livestock for sale at First Choice Aquatics in Flemington, NJ
First Choice Aquatics stocks corals, reef fish, invertebrates, aquarium plants and freshwater & saltwater fish for sale in Flemington, NJ. As an aquarium store serving Flemington, NJ, it also carries dry goods and fish food and offers tank maintenance, aquarium setup, aquascaping and aquarium consultations.
- Livestock & products
- Specializes in
Highlights
What makes them special
- Exceptional coral and frag selection with specimens described as mint condition
- Hosts the annual NJ Coral Show at Elkwood Lodge
- Owner Randy provides hands-on tank scaping and stocking assistance
- Saltwater tank maintenance program available
- Recently relocated to a larger, upgraded store
From keepers
Customer reviews
“Amazing little fish store! The owner is super friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely cares about the fish and their customers. The tanks are beautiful, the fish are healthy, and there’s a great selection to choose from. You can tell they put a lot of love and care into their business. It’s always nice to support a small local shop that truly cares about what they do. Highly recommend to anyone who loves fish or is looking to start their own aquarium! I’ll definitely be back!”
— Savannah Ryan5.0a day ago“Best fish store around I won’t go anywhere else. I’ve gotten all my supplies for every single one of my fish tanks right here. All the tanks are clean. They always have stock of new fish and staff is very knowledgeable.”
— Justin5.0a day ago“First visit at the store Staff knowledgeable, helpful and very friendly Good selection of fish, tanks well maintained.”
— Joseph Barberio5.02 days ago“Super friendly staff! Very helpful & knowledgeable! We started a fish tank about a year again and have been loving it!”
— Olivia Franklin5.03 days ago“Place sucks. Guy sold me a fish google said would die without specific care and feeding The guy didn’t care he wanted to make a quick buck. Poor fish died a few days later.”
— J Hu1.05 days ago“Friendly people and great assortment of fresh and saltwater fish”
— Matthew Gangi5.0a month ago“All the freshwater fish and inverts i get here are happy. My chili and strawberry rasboras are loving their life and super bright in color. I also got some aquatic plants from here and they're growing strong.”
— Danielle Smith5.02 months ago“Very professional and helped get a new fish purchased from them eating by recommending various foods.”
— John Spadaro5.0Edited 3 months ago“Tried calling this place 4 times during business hours. 3 went to the end of the line, 1 of them they picked up, never said anything, and then hung up 4 seconds later. Just wanted to see if they had something in stock before I drove 40 minutes each way, but oh well.”
— Tom T3.03 months ago“Jesi is an amazing employee! She was incredibly helpful and has so much knowledge about all the saltwater fish and corals, which made my experience great. She was so patient with me and took the time to explain everything clearly. I’ll definitely be coming back for her help!”
— Kreena Patel5.02 months ago
Reference
Frequently asked questions
Note — Store information and services may change. Always call (908) 751-5663 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting First Choice Aquatics.




