Paws and Claws & Company

Paws and Claws & Company in Warsaw, Indiana is one of those locally owned pet stores that earns its loyalty the old-fashioned way — through genuine care, quality products, and a staff that will literally carry your bags to the car. Owner Melissa has built a reputation for curating higher-quality pet foods, treats, and accessories than what you'd typically find at big box competitors, and her customers notice the difference. While Paws and Claws is primarily a pet supply store rather than a dedicated aquarium shop, they do maintain a freshwater fish section that draws families and hobbyists alike.

Multiple reviewers mention that children love coming in to look at the fish, and while the selection may be smaller than a specialty fish store, the quality is consistently praised. They're also a reliable source for live crickets — a detail reptile keepers in the Warsaw area will appreciate. The store's real strength is its product curation.

Freeze-dried treats get specific shout-outs from owners of picky dogs, and the emphasis on premium pet food brands sets them apart from chain retailers. Melissa is described as someone who would willingly accept a lower margin to ensure she's stocking products that are genuinely healthier for animals — a philosophy that resonates deeply with her customer base. The atmosphere inside is clean and welcoming, with dogs allowed to accompany their owners while shopping.

Walk-in nail clipping is a popular service, with several reviewers specifically praising how well the staff handles their pets during trims. One customer with mobility challenges described how employees not only helped locate items throughout the store but carried everything to checkout and then out to the car. 8 rating, Paws and Claws has clearly become Warsaw's go-to independent pet store.

It's the kind of place where the staff remembers your pet's name and your pet gets excited pulling into the parking lot.