Clear Creek Fisheries, LLC

Clear Creek Fisheries in Martinsville, Indiana isn't your typical fish store — it's a multi-generational family fishery that has been raising and selling pond and lake fish since the mid-20th century, with some customers tracing their relationship back to the 1970s. Tucked away on what feels like rural Indiana farmland, this is the go-to operation for anyone looking to stock a pond, farm lake, or private waterway with healthy, locally raised freshwater fish. The inventory reads like a pond owner's wish list: channel catfish, largemouth bass, bluegill, red ear sunfish, grass carp, flathead catfish, fathead minnows, and koi.

Orders can scale from a handful of koi for a backyard water feature to 200 largemouth bass for a full lake restocking. One customer picked up 150 channel cats and lost only eight — an impressive survival rate that speaks to the health of the fish leaving the facility. Another bought bluegill, bass, and catfish to rehabilitate a neglected pond, and within a year had clear water and thriving populations.

Eric, a staff member frequently mentioned by name, stands out for his willingness to answer questions, walk first-time pond owners through stocking plans, and provide honest recommendations on species ratios and pond management. The fishery offers same-day delivery for local orders, and customers consistently praise the call-ahead pickup process — phone in your order, show up, and your fish are bagged, oxygenated, and ready to go. The atmosphere is distinctly country.

Don't expect a polished retail showroom; expect a working fishery where the knowledge runs deep and the people are genuine. One reviewer fondly recalled hauling fish home in a cattle water tank with a jury-rigged aerator decades ago. That hands-on, practical spirit still defines the place.

For pond owners across central Indiana, Clear Creek Fisheries is an institution — the kind of family business that earns loyalty measured not in visits but in decades.