Exotic Aquatics and Pets

Exotic Aquatics and Pets in Kendallville, Indiana is a small, independently owned pet shop that draws customers from across Noble County and beyond — some driving an hour or more to browse its selection. The store stocks a broad range of freshwater fish, with reviewers noting tanks lining the back of the store filled with various species. They also carry saltwater fish and the equipment to support both types of setups, including canister filters and UV hanging lights sourced through a major national pet supplier.

If something isn't in stock, the owner is known for placing special orders. Beyond aquatics, the shop doubles as a small-animal and reptile destination. Customers have purchased axolotls, leopard geckos, ball pythons, bearded dragons, and more, alongside the supplies needed to house and care for them.

Birds, ferrets, chinchillas, guinea pigs, hamsters, and even sugar gliders have made appearances on the sales floor. One reviewer described getting all of their reptile setups here, from enclosures to accessories. The owner, often working the shop solo, earns praise for his knowledge and willingness to help troubleshoot tank issues and recommend products.

A staff member named Logan gets particular shout-outs for excellent service. Prices lean slightly higher than big-box competitors, but many customers see that as supporting a local business that offers personal expertise you won't find at a chain store. That said, the store has drawn consistent criticism about animal health.

Multiple reviewers report purchasing fish, hamsters, and guinea pigs that arrived sick or died shortly after purchase, and some have described unclean enclosures and unfinished areas in the shop. The owner has acknowledged growing pains and staffing challenges, and returning customers have noted improvement over time. For aquarium hobbyists and reptile keepers in northeastern Indiana looking for a local shop with hands-on help and a diverse inventory, Exotic Aquatics and Pets fills a niche that few stores in the area can match — just inspect animals carefully before purchasing.