The Mad Reefer in West Melbourne, Florida has built a loyal following among Space Coast reef keepers with its deep coral inventory and competitive pricing. The store's name tells you exactly what you're getting into — this is a saltwater-focused shop with roughly five coral display tanks that reviewers describe as gorgeous, stocked with pieces ranging from beginner-friendly options to expert-level specimens. Clownfish, watchman gobies, and clean-up crews move steadily out the door, and customers consistently report that livestock arrives healthy with excellent color.
Owner John is a central figure in the shop's identity. Regulars praise his encyclopedic reef knowledge and willingness to spend real time walking through questions — one visiting hobbyist from Cincinnati noted that John started spelling out product names and repeating key details when he noticed them taking notes. That kind of attentiveness has earned the store a dedicated customer base, particularly after another local reef shop, Little Reef, closed its doors.
Pricing is a frequent talking point. Multiple reviewers cite finding items at half the cost of competitors, and live rock prices in particular are called out as significantly more affordable than elsewhere. The dry goods selection is robust enough that several customers say they no longer need to order equipment online — one reviewer specifically found a digital salinity checker alongside a deep inventory of supplies.
The store also takes special orders and seems to turn them around quickly. It's worth noting that the experience can be inconsistent. A handful of reviews mention feeling ignored or encountering brusque interactions, and the store's small staff means wait times can stretch when someone is deep in conversation with another customer.
But the majority of the 182 reviews paint a picture of a passionate saltwater shop where the owner genuinely cares about the hobby and the animals. For reef enthusiasts on the Space Coast, The Mad Reefer delivers serious coral variety, fair prices, and the kind of specialized knowledge that keeps tanks thriving.
Robert Hankin
247 reviews
Just got our first fish, clean up crew and corals for our new tank. Everything is healthy, which is so important! And, the quality of what you get for the money is very impressive. I definitely recommend them, especially for the coral variety.
Heather McGuire
23 reviews
Prices are very reasonable. What i have found as 20.00 elsewhere, I found for 10.00 there
Michael Groesbeck
15 reviews
Best aquarium store ever!!! Totally awesome and the guys who run it are great with knowledge and will answer all your questions. Check them out you will be glad you did!
Thomas Reddy
14 reviews
Always straight up Great for advice staff is well knowledged
Scott S
35 reviews
Went here because our local store was closed. Was telling the guy there that the other place was closed and was nice to see a new store. Before I could finish my sentence the guy working there flew off the handle about how I shopped somewhere else. Looked at the other guy working there and said don't help them. I left in awe that an employee was so fragile and Insecure. Good luck, but you won't get any of my business.
Deborah Kenny
2 reviews
On occasion I stop at the Mad Reefer with my son. I love that store! The owners are friendly and are happy to answer some questions I may have. The fish Selection is beautiful and the owner is happy to answer any questions. I now look forward to going to the fish store! Beautiful Fish, great, friendly service.
Meghan Whitfield
4 reviews
Absolutely love this aquarium store! My boyfriend and I visit all the time. John, the owner, is incredibly knowledgeable and always so kind and helpful. His prices are fantastic, truly the best value you’ll find in the area. Highly recommend!
Bob Brown
3 reviews
I went there for the first time. After I looked around I was ready to buy some fish for my tank. There was some guy, presumably the owner, talking to a customer. After about 15 minutes the guy was still talking. I stood about 3 feet away just looking at him. Never once did he or anyone else working there say, I’ll be right with you, and , when he finally shut up, I was still standing there 3 feet away when he just walked towards the cash register without even looking at me or asking if I needed anything. I’ll never go back and l suggest that the whole bunch take some customer service classes. Nahackneys , excuse the spelling, is so much better.
John Walsh
10 reviews
The best coral and fish store. John cares about his customers, and livestock and it shows!
Chris Kushmer
14 reviews
Guy was ok i seen bad reviews but from me it's was nice he turned me on to some apitasa stuff that I didn't no about he had some nice corals
Note: Store information and services may change. Always call (321) 345-4723 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting The Mad Reefer.
Phone
(321) 345-4723Website
www.madreefercorals.com/Address
630 S Wickham Rd #206, West Melbourne, FL 32904
Take control of your listing to update info and respond to reviews.
Claim This ListingFind on Map
630 S Wickham Rd #206, West Melbourne, FL 32904
February 7, 2026
Verified Data
Information verified through Google Places API and community contributions.
Other aquarium shops nearby worth checking out