About
Carol's Critters is the kind of independent, family-run pet store that Tallahassee aquarists guard like a secret, and for many of them it's simply the only place they'll buy fish. The storefront stocks reptiles, birds, turtles, snakes, and small animals too, but regulars keep coming back week after week for a freshwater fish section that punches well above the size of the room. " The aquarium section stays genuinely well stocked, with affordable freshwater livestock that ranges from budget goldfish (famously six for a dollar on the right day) to angelfish for sale in Tallahassee, FL, plus the shrimp that local turtle keepers swing by to grab.
" If a supply or tank accessory isn't on the shelf, the team will special order it. What makes the place stick is Carol herself and a counter crew that treats a ten-dollar shopper the same as a hundred-dollar one. Visitors describe staff who "immediately helped me get exactly what I needed," patient feeding and tank advice, and an owner who's been known to keep helping customers care for animals they didn't even buy here.
The footprint is small and admittedly cramped, the parking tight, but that closeness is exactly why the staff knows every tank on the wall. For anyone hunting a dependable local fish store near me in Tallahassee, with healthy freshwater fish, fair prices, and honest guidance from people who clearly love the hobby, Carol's Critters has earned its loyal following one tank at a time.
What they offer
Fish & livestock for sale at Carol's Critters in Tallahassee, FL
Carol's Critters stocks goldfish, angelfish, shrimp and freshwater fish for sale in Tallahassee, FL. As a fish store serving Tallahassee, FL, it also carries aquarium equipment and offers aquarium consultations.
- Livestock & products
- GoldfishAngelfishShrimpAquarium Equipment
- Services
- Specializes in
Highlights
What makes them special
- Regulars call it the best fish shop in Tallahassee — small, quaint, and full of neat finds
- Healthy, well-stocked freshwater section; staff who 'know how to catch fish properly'
- Affordable livestock including goldfish (six for a dollar), angelfish, and shrimp for turtle keepers
- Owner Carol and her counter crew give patient, honest advice to every shopper
- Will special order supplies and tank gear they don't keep in stock
From keepers
Customer reviews
“Best pet supply store I've been to! The guy working the counter was super helpful and immediately helped me get exactly what I needed!”
— Elijah5.03 days ago“I get all my pets things here great service and prices”
— mabrye bettinger5.0a week ago“I always have the coolest pets”
— Chris Hodges4.03 weeks ago“Very helpful and knowledgeable staff!”
— Sarah5.0a month ago“Been using carols for years, always super friendly and professional”
— Ben Lyles5.0a month ago“Always enjoy visiting Carol's critters. It the only real pet store in Tallahassee.”
— Matt Soteros5.02 months ago“Carol and I go back a long time. I had several pet shops. Carol's is the best place to buy your pet supplies and the fish are always healthy. The reason, they know how to catch fish properly. I've never had a fish die from there. I also like how friendly the employees are. Carol is a people person and you can tell she enjoys what she does as I did. This contributed to success. I recently gave several aquariums away and told the new owners to buy from Carol's Critters.”
— Lahua Mahoney5.02 months ago“Very well stocked aquarium section.”
— Xx Unah xX5.02 months ago“I got a bird from her that came with SEVERE brain swelling and it ended up dying 4 days later. I called Carol herself and asked for a refund or a new bird and she tried to tell me it was my fault and to bring my giant bird cage, the food, and my dead bird (which I already buried) to her store and even with that she won’t give me a refund but she will “work with me” ARE YOU KIDDING ME????? NEVER going back again. PETSMART treats their animals better AND they have a warranty. GO TO PETSMART INSTEAD!”
— Coco Gillis1.02 months ago“Great place to shop for your pets! Employees are always nice and super helpful. I'm always in to grab stuff for my snake and to say hi to all of critters they have 😁”
— Ryan Dever5.02 months ago
Reference
Frequently asked questions
Note — Store information and services may change. Always call (850) 574-6199 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Carol's Critters.