Splash Supply Company in York, Pennsylvania isn't your typical fish store — it's a full-service pond destination with a retail showroom that reviewers describe as genuinely stunning. The property features elaborate water feature displays, including a swimming pond stocked with koi so tame they'll nibble your fingers and practically let you lift them out of the water. Fancy goldfish for sale are equally friendly, a testament to how well the fish are cared for here.
Owner Mark and his team handle every stage of the pond experience, from custom design and installation to deep cleans and seasonal maintenance. Customers rave about major builds — lily pad ponds, multi-waterfall systems with lighting, skimmer installations, extensive rock work and plumbing — all executed by crews described as energetic, detail-oriented, and respectful of the property. One customer had an entire pond built before her birthday party deadline.
Another hired them for repairs so thorough the pond looked better than new. The retail side carries everything a pond owner needs: koi, goldfish, pond-side plants, water treatments, and supplies for ponds of various sizes (though a few reviewers note the inventory skews toward medium and larger setups). Staff like Kelly and Becky earn personal shoutouts for walking customers through plant and fish selection without pressure.
Water testing is offered on-site — bring in a sample and they'll assess whether your pond is ready for fish, then advise on proper maintenance without pushing unnecessary products. Splash also hosts open house events and educational seminars, making it a community hub for pond enthusiasts across central Pennsylvania. Several reviewers drive over an hour to visit, though a few have noted difficulty reaching the store by phone.
The koi come with a health warranty, and the garden area surrounding the store is the kind of place where customers say they'd happily sit with their morning coffee. For anyone building, maintaining, or dreaming about a backyard water feature in the York area, Splash Supply is the real deal.
Jim Hutchins
9 reviews
Called them going up 83 and only had a few minutes to spare and they had my order ready when I got there and was very easy to deal with
Len Barnickel
3 reviews
I have called multiple times and left a message. Not once has anyone ever called back. I live over an hour away and would like to know before I make the trip. I call and it says option 2 for store . Never has anyone ever pick up the phone. So I have left messages to call me. Never. The place is nice and the staff are very knowledgeable and friendly. Just call back when someone leaves a message. Thank you for the call back.
Matt Vicino
Absolutely love Splash!!!! Very professional and awesome people. Bought the lotus pond last year and this year added another small pond with a patio. Fantastic work and everything looks amazing. Thank you Mark.
Carlee Shoemaker
5 reviews
We walked in for the “open house” I saw from the road as we were driving by and I was excited because I’m in the market for a pond. Never even heard of the place. We walked around outside a bit. However, upon entering the building, we were met with glaring looks from every employee standing right at the front and received no acknowledgment whatsoever. Not a single greeting or a simple “Hi, how are you?”. This kind of behavior is completely unacceptable and is a major turn-off for a consumer, if at least one person would have said at least one thing to us we would have been purchasing something. What a marketing flop…advertise and have a open house to obviously get people in the door, your product and business out there/have sales ect. But to not even make no acknowledgment to a customer. As soon as we had that awkward experience we left. All around confusing experience.
Derricka Kimmel
3 reviews
Everything I could dream for in a pond shop! Sadly we are not local to the area, but if we were I would definitely be a regular customer! They have all the supplies you need to care for your own pond, gorgeous displays, and I’m sure knowledge and know-how as well. The fish were one of my favorite parts. The koi in the swim pond came right up to us, allowing us to pet them as they nibbled our fingers. Similarly the fancy goldfish they had for sale were so tame they could almost be lifted out of the water in your hands.
ROBERT WOLFGANG
2 reviews
The team was very energetic, very hard working and watching was more than fun. The finished pond was fantastic. We are so pleased with our new pond and so are the fish.
Beth Hilt
5 reviews
My pond is beyond my expectations. Every step in the process was great and the pond is so much better than I could even imagine. The team that did the work was amazing. In 90+ degree days they worked so hard. Highly recommend the entire team at Splash.
Evelynn Eighmey
15 reviews
bought koi from them. Very healthy and came with a warranty!
Ben Rehmeyer
7 reviews
Had Splash Supply out to do a deep clean on my pond after moving into a new house. They communicated very well about scheduling and then the crew doing the cleanup did a great job getting everything the way I wanted and teaching me about my equipment. They took very good care of my fish and frogs during the cleaning as well. Highly recommend their service!
Reid Johnson
17 reviews
They did a beautiful job, they also provide excellent follow up with any concerns or issues. Highly recommend them.
Note: Store information and services may change. Always call (717) 751-2108 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Splash Supply Company.
Phone
(717) 751-2108Address
1941 Powder Mill Rd, York, PA 17402
Take control of your listing to update info and respond to reviews.
Claim This ListingFind on Map
1941 Powder Mill Rd, York, PA 17402
February 7, 2026
Verified Data
Information verified through Google Places API and community contributions.
Other aquarium shops nearby worth checking out