








Felicity's Pet Supplies in Bellefonte, Pennsylvania, is a woman-owned pet supply store that has earned a devoted following thanks to owner Sheena's remarkable dedication to quality and personalized service. Named after the store's canine mascot — a friendly pup who greets visitors alongside the staff — this shop has become a cornerstone of the local pet community. What sets Felicity's apart is Sheena's meticulous approach to product curation.
Every item on the shelves has been researched for quality ingredients and nutritional value, with a focus on limited and single-ingredient treats, premium chews, and high-quality food for dogs and cats. Customers dealing with pet allergies, ear infections, or prescription diet requirements have found a trusted ally in Sheena, who takes the time to understand each animal's specific needs and breed characteristics. If she doesn't carry a particular food, she'll order it.
If she doesn't know the answer to a question, she'll research it and follow up. The personal touches are what customers talk about most. Sheena remembers pets by name, recalls their favorite products, and even knew which frozen bones to pull when a family member stopped in on a customer's behalf.
The store runs a rewards program for food bag purchases, a birthday club that sends cards to pets on their special day, and a program offering free goodies to customers who've recently adopted a pet. Throughout the year, Felicity's hosts community events and collection drives for local animal rescues. The store also ships nationally — a customer in New York raves about fast, well-packed regular shipments — extending Sheena's careful product selection beyond central Pennsylvania.
Dogs visiting the shop are greeted with affection and treats (and occasionally fresh pancakes with toppings during special events), making every trip feel like a celebration. For pet owners in the Bellefonte area who care deeply about what they feed their animals, Felicity's has become the only stop they need.
Carolyn Yates
4 reviews
The store owner was very knowledgeable about my dog’s needs for enrichment. She recommended a great toy for feeding/enrichment and joint support drops for her old legs. I haven’t tried the drops yet but my dog loves the enrichment toy! I also got to meet sweet Felicity, the store mascot so that was a plus. This store has a lot to offer and Sheena (store owner) is super helpful and an expert!
Jessica Martz
10 reviews
While we don't visit as often as we would like, but Sheena still greets me by name and knows our dog's name. The store has a great selection of high quality food, treats, and toys. Our dog Loki can get a little overstimulated and the staff is so patient when he goes from calm to crazy.
Emma Hartke
13 reviews
The absolute best! I visit on a bi-weekly basis to purchase frozen bones for my dogs and Sheena (and the rest of the Felicity’s team) is always so kind, attentive, and helpful! Truly a pleasure when I get the chance to stop in. Sheena was especially helpful recently when a family member stopped in to buy dog bones on my behalf, but couldn’t remember which kind. They mentioned my name and Sheena knew exactly the ones! :-)
Mike Maloney
4 reviews
I stopped by today for the first time to pickup my two dogs food and I was so blown away by the selection and cleanliness of the store. My dogs struggle with allergies and ear infections and I really want to ensure that I’m feeding them a quality diet. So happy to know about this store now. The staff also could not be friendlier and even greeted my two dogs. They were so nice to give them some affection and even some treats. I even met Felicity, the boss 🐶. What a wonderful experience.
Meggan MacDonald
4 reviews
Felicity’s Pet Supply is the only pet store that I will go to. Sheena is so knowledgeable about the products and I fully trust her advice to keep my dog happy and healthy.
Abby Rote
3 reviews
I LOVE getting any treats and chews here for my dog! Although he does not have any allergies or sensitives, that we are aware of, Sheena always makes sure to ask when doing any mystery baskets; her thoughtfulness is UNMATCHED! Giving my dog limited/single ingredient treats/chews is such a nice feeling to have. Sheena does her research and always gives unbiased information for anything dog related!
Susan Ross
6 reviews
Absolutely love this local, woman-owned, pet supply store in Bellefonte PA. The owner genuinely cares about her customers and their animals' needs. She also is very community-minded and hosts numerous events throughout the year for locals, holds collection events for the local animal rescues, and provides shop visitors with top-notch customer service.
Magpie Interiors LLC
13 reviews
The folks at Felicity’s really know their stuff! My dog is looking so much healthier since I’ve been following their recommendations. I highly recommend you shop local with Felicity’s!
Meghan Hamorsky
10 reviews
I like shopping here because the owner is knowledgeable and gives great recommendations. You can tell she loves pets and wants the best for them! I feel comfortable shopping for food and treats here because they are all quality ingredients, no fillers. Also, they offer a rewards program for buying pet food there. Finally, they offer a sweet program that rewards you with free goodies if you've recently adopted a pet!
Diana Coudriet-Donegan
37 reviews
First time customer - new to the area and so happy to have found a great pet store with many healthy choices to choose from. Staff was super friendly and they even had fresh pancakes with toppings for any doggie visitors! Will definitely go back!
Note: Store information and services may change. Always call (814) 400-4898 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Felicity's Pet Supplies.
Phone
(814) 400-4898Address
2022 Axemann Rd Suite 101, Bellefonte, PA 16823
Take control of your listing to update info and respond to reviews.
Claim This ListingFind on Map
2022 Axemann Rd Suite 101, Bellefonte, PA 16823
February 7, 2026
Verified Data
Information verified through Google Places API and community contributions.
Other aquarium shops nearby worth checking out