About
Whiting's Pet Supplies in Glen Lyon, Pennsylvania is a dedicated pet supply shop that has earned a loyal following across the Back Mountain community and beyond. Originally located in Dallas, the store relocated to Glen Lyon but kept its devoted customers making the drive — a testament to the trust and relationships the owners have built over the years. Don't be misled by the storefront's modest appearance.
Reviewers consistently note that once you step inside, the inventory is surprisingly deep and well-curated. The shop stocks a wide range of pet food, bedding, treats, and accessories for dogs, cats, bunnies, and other animals, with a particular emphasis on high-end and specialty pet foods that customers say they can't find elsewhere. One bunny owner specifically praised the reasonable pricing on foraging food, while dog owners appreciate the quality food brands and the store's loyalty program that rewards repeat purchases.
It's worth noting that Whiting's does not carry live animals — this is strictly a supplies shop. While they don't stock large aquarium equipment on-site, they do offer ordering services for specialty items. The focus here is on knowledgeable, personal service and curated product selection rather than trying to be a big-box competitor.
The staff and owners are the heart of this operation. Review after review highlights their willingness to answer questions, offer product guidance, and make genuine connections with customers. The owners clearly know their products and the animals they serve, and that expertise keeps people coming back month after month.
A loyalty program sweetens the deal for regular shoppers stocking up on dog food and other staples. For pet owners in the Glen Lyon and Back Mountain area looking for quality supplies, personalized service, and competitive pricing on premium brands, Whiting's is the kind of independent shop that makes supporting local businesses feel easy.
Highlights
What makes them special
- Surprisingly large inventory of high-end and specialty pet foods
- Loyalty program for regular customers
- Knowledgeable owners who provide personalized product guidance
- Competitive pricing on premium pet food brands
- Can special-order items not stocked in store
From keepers
Customer reviews
“What a fantastic little gem. The staff is amazing, store is amazing. guarantee after you visit one time.It will be your main pet supplier from here on out”
— Matt Osnap5.03 months ago“They are very helpful with the pet food questions. I would recommend them”
— Alex Makavensky5.0a year ago“Love this place. The owners are amazing!”
— Tresha Butler5.0a year ago“Nice owners and have good prices”
— Pat Dougherty5.02 years ago“No live animals”
— Dave Wodarczyk1.02 years ago“Quality pet supplies great prices. Don't let the size of this place fool you. Once inside, it has a great inventory.”
— DJ Neil5.03 years ago“Love this place. Use to shop there when it was at Dallas. I still go even though they're in Glen Lyon now. Nice staff and I like to help local businesses. They have a HUGE selection of literally everything for your pets.”
— Jude ODomhnaill5.04 years ago“Good service, good prices”
— Dave Theisen5.05 years ago“Went there twice NASTY RUDE owner!!!!!!!! Will NOT be going back!!!!! She has NO business working with the public with that attitude!!!!! Not even worth 1 star!!!”
— Patti Smith1.05 years ago“Very knowledgeable & friendly staff!!!”
— Galvin Duesler5.05 years ago
Reference
Frequently asked questions
Note — Store information and services may change. Always call (570) 733-2011 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Whiting’s Pet Supplies.


