About
Jurassic Aquatics & Pets is tucked inside the Willoughby Target parking lot, up on the hill by the stop sign between Target and Giant Eagle, on the same side as Starbucks and the bin store. It is genuinely hard to find the first time, but regulars know it as one of the few independent spots in Lake County stocking both freshwater and saltwater livestock. Walk in and you will find freshwater staples like cichlids and bristlenose plecos for sale in Willoughby, OH, alongside snails, hermit crabs, and other invertebrates, plus a rotating saltwater section and the occasional rare species you will not spot elsewhere in the greater Cleveland area.
" That said, this aquarium store carries a deeply divided reputation, and recent visitors keep raising the same concerns. A steady stream of reviews describes a strong odor on entry, tanks clouded with algae, mold on some of the for-sale stands, merchandise scattered across the floor, and reptile enclosures that shoppers feel fall short on heat, hides, and clean water. Several people report contacting the Lake Humane Society and, more recently, the Willoughby police.
One June visitor did note staff actively cleaning during his stop, so day-to-day conditions seem to vary. If you shop here, go in with eyes open: inspect any fish or invertebrate before buying, ask the owner detailed questions about compatibility, and plan to quarantine and observe anything you bring home. The bones of a solid neighborhood fish store are here — freshwater and saltwater stock available in Willoughby, OH, fair prices, and an owner who clearly knows his saltwater — but the persistent cleanliness and animal-welfare reports mean it pays to look closely before you commit.
What they offer
Fish & livestock for sale at Jurassic Aquatics & Pets in Willoughby, OH
Jurassic Aquatics & Pets stocks cichlids, plecos, invertebrates and freshwater & saltwater fish for sale in Willoughby, OH. As an aquarium store serving Willoughby, OH, it also carries aquarium equipment.
- Livestock & products
- Specializes in
Highlights
What makes them special
- One of the few Lake County shops carrying both freshwater and saltwater livestock
- Freshwater selection includes cichlids and bristlenose plecos, plus snails and other invertebrates
- Tucked in the Willoughby Target parking lot by the stop sign near Starbucks — hard to find
- Competitive pricing and an owner praised for saltwater advice; second-hand tanks often in stock
- Persistent reviewer concerns about odor, tank cleanliness, and animal welfare
From keepers
Customer reviews
“I walked in knowing the reputation this place carries, but still with an open mind. I have to say out of all the places locally (blue fish, agnoquatics, great lakes, etc.) this place is by far the least taken care of. A majority of their tanks were filthy, although I did walk in to them cleaning, so I'm hoping I caught them on an off day. For what it's worth, this is also the stinkiest fish/pet shop I've ever walked into. I'd almost recommend going across the lot to PetSmart for your fish needs, or even taking the 20 minute trip to my personal favorite spot, blue fish in Lyndhurst.”
— Jerome Rolf2.04 hours ago“if you have basic care experience and knowledge, need i say anymore? this place is horrible. reptiles and others have been kept in horrible care for years as far as the reviews go…if that gecko isn’t dead then it damn sure is not healthy. Humane Society and Willoughby police were contacted already and have received numerous complaints but the place still seems to be in business. Owner is kind but nasty and in denial when confronted. Stop giving these people money to mistreat and kill off more animals. If you care for your own animals and still financially support this place, you are apart of the problem and you are helping continue this cycle.”
— taleahhh howze1.0a week ago“This is one Jive!!!! Dude.He trys fast talking you.Will sale you fish that don't Mix! For a sale.Beware!!!! He's smooth.Never ever will I return. Blue aquarium on Mayfield A1 Service!!!!!!”
— rick owens1.0a month ago“I have called the lake humane society over a year ago about the poor treatment of these animals and nothing has happened, still dead animals all around and horrible smelling store”
— Austin McCourt1.02 months ago“Knowledge staff and great selection!”
— Courtney Jones5.02 months ago“Never fails. Every single time weather it is a phone call or going in the store personally. Every single damn person is always so unbelievably rude, nasty & miserable. They obviously should just close up shop if they hate their customers that freaking bad.....”
— Vivianne O'Malley1.02 months ago“Dirty, very unorganized”
— Stu1.03 months ago“We went there Sunday, surprised to see it actually open and wish we didn't after seeing the very poor conditions every single creature was in. I've even had nightmares about it.”
— Stephanie Bowen1.03 months ago“So many awful things wrong. Between the smell of mold and mildew, to the treatment of these poor animals. Everything is scattered everywhere. Nothing is priced. These poor babies aren’t taken care of. I wish I could Rescue all of them, but I’d never give a dime to these animal abusive people.”
— Chloes Mama1.03 months ago“Walked in and immediately wanted to walk out. Smelled so bad, tanks were nasty and not to mention majority of them were empty. The tanks with the fish were also nasty with half dead fish in them. Definitely will not be returning or recommending anyone to shop here unfortunately.”
— Kay Nicole1.03 months ago
Reference
Frequently asked questions
Note — Store information and services may change. Always call +1 440-510-8205 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Jurassic Aquatics & Pets.