Tucked away in Valley City, Ohio, Aquatica Aquarium Gallery draws fishkeepers from over an hour away — and they keep coming back. The store is packed wall-to-wall with hundreds of tanks spanning both freshwater and saltwater livestock, from lionfish and ghost knives to hammer corals and shrimp suited for nano setups. Reviewers consistently note the health of the animals, with one coral buyer remarking on zero pests and thriving hammers, crediting the store's use of macroalgae for natural filtration — a detail rarely seen in retail aquarium shops.
The plant selection is a standout. Staff members like Luke actively notify customers when specific plants arrive, and the hardscape section, managed by knowledgeable team members like Jordan, offers an impressive variety of rocks and stones with guidance on compatibility for different aquarium setups. A unique gravel table lets customers experiment with combinations of natural decorations before committing — a hands-on touch that speaks to how seriously Aquatica takes aquascaping.
The freshwater planted tank community will find everything they need here, including supplies for large-scale builds. One customer running a 480-gallon planted tank with a 100-gallon sump reported finding everything on their list. On the saltwater side, the store stocks reef corals and carries brands like Red Sea, though custom delivery and installation services have drawn mixed feedback.
Staff member Lindsay has helped customers design and build nano aquariums from scratch, and Kim earns praise for patient, educational interactions with newer hobbyists. Pricing opinions vary — some find it reasonable and competitive with area shops, while others note certain species like rope fish and plecos carry a premium compared to nearby competitors. But the consensus is clear: the livestock quality, massive selection, and genuinely helpful staff — Steve, Josh, Jordan, Luke, Kim, Lindsay — make the drive worthwhile.
The store feels wonderfully overstuffed, described by one visitor as having the energy of a New York deli, but with fish tanks instead of sandwich boards.
Chris Czarnik
5 reviews
Good selection at good prices. Ordered a protein skimmer, and received it the next day. Very pleasant customer service.
William.a EGAN
102 reviews
Best place fish products for fish tank. Talk steve
Lauren Slys
10 reviews
Great shop! Wide variety of plants and hard scape items. Nice stock of fish. Beautiful custom display tanks and very knowledgeable staff! The owner is very friendly and helpful as well! Will be returning
Carol Smith
90 reviews
I truly love this store. Luke has been absolutely a diamond helped me with so much from advice, to getting and calling me when fish and plants arrive that i am in need of. Just met Jordan over in the rock and stone area very helpful and great to chat to about what rocks to use and how to tell if good for certain aquarium set ups. With them both ill be onto my 55 gal in no time. Thanks Aquatica Luke and Jordan
Joppa H
24 reviews
What a great place to shop for your aquarium needs. The staff is some of the most helpful and knowledgeable people around. I don't mind making the hour long drive because they have one of the biggest selections of fish and supplies in the area. I love this store
TAZ CAT
7 reviews
Hands down the best place for the fish keeping adventure! This store has it all. Beautiful healthy fish, top notch aquarium products and by far the best employees. They go above and beyond to help and educate the customer. A personal thank you to Jordan. Every time my wife and I stop by he makes sure that we have been taken care of. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND! IT'S A MUST GO TO!! Thanks again for everything!
Andy Royer
5 reviews
Best place around! Great customer service! Steve and the whole crew always go above and beyond!
Pete
3 reviews
Super knowledgeable and friendly. help a hobbyist who now knows fish better
Eric
3 reviews
I would not recommend this store. I was in the market for a large, 184g S-850 MAX Red Sea aquarium however wanted to be sure to purchase from a store that could also do the moving into the location of my basement as it’s a very large and heavy tank! That was my only ask prior to purchasing an 11k aquarium. I spoke with the owner who said he would do a site visit to check on this location for me, however later said through text that he would only come to determine the location possibility after the “transaction is finalized”. How does this make any sense? Are you going to refund me 11k if you determine the location is not possible to move the aquarium to? I would avoid this place. My new Red Sea aquarium is now in its spot and all is well, thanks to another shop.
Tony Livecchi
4 reviews
Went in for the first time recently and they have a great inventory selection and the employees seem to be very knowledgeable with everything related to the hobby! Highly recommend!
Note: Store information and services may change. Always call (330) 866-0559 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Aquatica Aquarium Gallery.
Take control of your listing to update info and respond to reviews.
Claim This ListingFind on Map
6653 Grafton Rd, Valley City, OH 44280
February 7, 2026
Verified Data
Information verified through Google Places API and community contributions.
Other aquarium shops nearby worth checking out