About
Gordon's Aquatics LLC in Plymouth, Ohio is a small-town pet shop that deals in tropical fish along with food and supplies. The store operates with a personal touch that's increasingly rare in the aquarium hobby — one reviewer recounted calling ahead to ask about specific livestock availability, and when the desired fish wasn't in stock, the owner arranged to have it brought in the following Thursday and even opened the shop on an off day so a young customer could pick it up. That kind of accommodation speaks to the independent, owner-operated nature of the business.
Reviewers consistently highlight the friendliness of the staff and the willingness to offer advice, which can be invaluable for freshwater fishkeepers navigating stocking decisions or troubleshooting tank issues. The store carries a selection of supplies alongside its live tropical fish, making it a convenient one-stop option for hobbyists in the Plymouth area who might otherwise face a long drive to larger retailers. It should be noted that the store has drawn some criticism regarding tank cleanliness and livestock care, with one reviewer expressing concern about the condition of certain display tanks.
This is worth keeping in mind, and prospective buyers should inspect fish carefully before purchasing — a good practice at any shop. For aquarium hobbyists in north-central Ohio, Gordon's Aquatics fills a niche as a local source for tropical freshwater fish and supplies. The personalized service — phone consultations, special orders, flexible hours for pickups — sets it apart from big-box alternatives.
If you're in the Plymouth area and looking for livestock or dry goods for your freshwater setup, it's worth stopping in to see what's currently in stock and to take advantage of the hands-on guidance the staff provides.
What they offer
Fish & livestock for sale at Gordon’s Aquatics LLC in Plymouth, OH
Gordon’s Aquatics LLC stocks freshwater fish for sale in Plymouth, OH. As a fish store serving Plymouth, OH, it also carries dry goods.
- Livestock & products
- Dry Goods
- Specializes in
Highlights
What makes them special
- Personalized service including special orders and flexible pickup arrangements
- Tropical freshwater fish and aquarium supplies available
- Staff offers hands-on advice for fishkeeping questions
- Locally owned independent shop serving north-central Ohio
From keepers
Customer reviews
“Took returns for Amazon but they wouldn't give receipt for return not evan a tracking number. Left going somewhere else.”
— catherine link1.0a month ago“Great place for Amazon return s”
— Chuck Leskovec4.02 months ago“Fun pet store with helpful associates and lots of selection of all kinds of animals.”
— Brian Koebele5.02 months ago“Great Service”
— Owen Williams5.0a week ago“Really friendly staff. Had everything I needed and great advice.”
— Joshua Brown5.05 months ago“Wonderful experience! We called and talked to him about what he had available. He didn't have what my daughter was looking for but he would be getting it in the next Thursday. They aren't normally open then and he still let her come in to pick it up. Very friendly and a great selection of supplies.”
— Seth Howell5.06 months ago“Store is absolutely filthy and the animals need to be cared for. Some tanks have nothing but dead fish. The person behind the counter needs to clean and care for the animals. She isn't doing anything!”
— John Lovelady1.08 months ago“Healthy stock, great service!😊”
— Jenny Barnett4.0a year ago“First time here and barely any fish. Just left a few minutes ago and there was a lady at the checkout that didn't even acknowledge our presence which was odd and left us feeling very unwelcome. Fish tanks looked rough too. Tried to call and no one answered. Left a sour taste in my mouth. Hopefully when we come back in a couple weeks things will be different. I love supporting small businesses, but this is a hard one to consider coming back to”
— Katelyn Shoemaker1.0a year ago“Good prices and very friendly”
— Tim Wilson5.02 years ago
Reference
Frequently asked questions
Note — Store information and services may change. Always call (419) 687-1049 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Gordon’s Aquatics LLC.