Something Fishy Inc

Something Fishy Inc. on Cleveland's east side carries the spirit of the old-school neighborhood fish store — the kind you remember walking into as a kid, walls lined with bubbling tanks and the quiet hum of filters. It's a family-run operation where Dave and Adam are the faces behind the counter, and regulars swear by their deep expertise, particularly when it comes to cichlids.

One devoted customer credits the duo with helping them start and maintain a cichlid tank from scratch, even stepping in to save a struggling fish. That level of hands-on guidance is hard to find at any chain store. The shop stocks a solid variety of freshwater fish, including angelfish and cichlids, alongside aquarium supplies like driftwood, rocks, and live plants — the sort of unique décor pieces that big-box retailers rarely carry.

Tanks on display are consistently noted for being clean with clear water, a detail that speaks to the care behind the scenes. Whether you're picking up food, accessories, or your next fish, the inventory leans toward the curated rather than the overwhelming. That said, Something Fishy has its quirks.

Some visitors have found the selection thinner than expected, and the store keeps tight hours — arriving even a few minutes early can mean a closed door despite it being unlocked. It's the kind of place that rewards those who come during posted hours and are ready to ask questions. When the staff is in their element, they're engaged and generous with their knowledge, walking customers through compatibility, feeding, and tank health.

For Cleveland freshwater enthusiasts looking for a local shop with personality, genuine cichlid expertise, and a personal touch that disappeared from most pet retail years ago, Something Fishy delivers an experience that's increasingly rare. Just check the hours on that yellow sign before you head over.