Fish N' Stuff has been a fixture of Athens, Ohio since 1982, and walking through its doors you immediately understand why it's endured for over four decades. Owner Mike and his brother run a tight, clean operation — reviewers consistently note that this is one of the cleanest fish stores they've encountered, with well-maintained tanks that make it easy to browse and identify species. The shop serves both freshwater and saltwater hobbyists, and the livestock selection rotates frequently enough that regular visitors find something new on each trip.
The live fish are healthy and varied. Customers have had particular success with angelfish that grew from half-dollar size into thriving specimens, ghost shrimp that settled in without issue, and live plants that complement planted tank setups. Neon tetras are also in the mix, though as any fishkeeper knows, those can be finicky regardless of source.
Beyond fish, the store stocks a solid range of substrates, décor, aquariums, terrariums, and both live and dry foods — essentially everything needed to maintain a freshwater or saltwater setup without driving to a big-box retailer. Fish N' Stuff is also a significant reptile destination in Athens. Bearded dragons, snakes, and an assortment of feeder insects — including mealworms bred in-house, which customers rave about for their quality and affordability — keep the reptile crowd coming back.
Crickets and other bugs are reliably stocked. Mike's willingness to special-order animals and live foods adds a personal touch you won't find at chain stores. He's known for taking time with customers, walking them through product options and animal care.
The pricing is consistently described as reasonable, often the best in the area for both livestock and supplies. For aquarium enthusiasts in southeastern Ohio, Fish N' Stuff offers the rare combination of rotating, well-cared-for stock, genuine expertise from a long-time owner, and the kind of fair pricing that keeps people loyal for 25 years and counting.
HUI ZHAN
22 reviews
lovely
D Lynn
5 reviews
Well cared for critters n fish. Great selection of reptile and fishtank substrates, carries everything you need to care for the pets available there!
Roger
5 reviews
Great store nice people.
Eldona Miller
4 reviews
I’ve been shopping here over 25 years the owner and his brother are both friendly. The animals in stock are always changing you’ll see the normal fish every pet shop has and you see different species at random times keeping the find more interesting for us aquarium lovers. They have a good selection of plants. Live foods dry foods, aquariums and terrariums as well as decors substrates and more. By far the best pricing in the area yes each worker has different knowledge of different animals so some may be orders waiting for pick up so there tanks aren’t what you would expect a setup to look like. I’ve ordered animals in advance as well as live foods. Plus there local and not a big chain store
Josh Fouss
16 reviews
Very bright and clean place. The fish tanks are easy to see what's inside and figure out what kind of fish are which. Staff is very nice and helpful also.
Trista
15 reviews
Great verity of animals to choose from prices are decent. Been in business since 1982
gabe greer
12 reviews
The cashier was polite and informative when I made my request of certain foods needed for my snakes along with my tarantulas. Also didn't mind my perusal of their stock.
Kyuu
I’ve been going to this store since I was 10 years old, I’m now 24. Mike the owner of the store has been nothing but helpful and supportive especially when it comes to getting knowledge about the animals and products they carry. Mike has always been professional and helpful. This is the only fish store we have left in Athens I wish to treasure it for as long as possible. Mike has always helped me out with fresh water, salt water, or non aquatic things. He is a very kind hearted person who deserves recognition and appreciation not just for being kind but helpful and resourceful. If you have any questions or concerns he will definitely put your mind at ease and explain any questions you may have. I love supporting this local business he definitely deserves it.
Daniel Schlueter
70 reviews
Love this shop!
heather shonk
3 reviews
I found the little fish store to check out and now its my favorite. This fish store maintains very reasonable prices and is probably one of the cleanest stores I've ever been. I love this place.
Note: Store information and services may change. Always call (740) 592-5974 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting Fish N' Stuff.
Take control of your listing to update info and respond to reviews.
Claim This ListingFind on Map
4 Station St, Athens, OH 45701
February 7, 2026
Verified Data
Information verified through Google Places API and community contributions.
Other aquarium shops nearby worth checking out