Fins on Fifth

Fins on Fifth sits in downtown Hendersonville, North Carolina, operating as a small-town pet shop with a broad inventory that extends well beyond fish. The store stocks freshwater fish, axolotls, dwarf pea puffers, and saltwater supplies alongside reptiles like ball pythons, bearded dragons, and uromastyx, plus small mammals including sugar gliders, rabbits, and guinea pigs. It's a non-traditional pet store in the truest sense — you're as likely to leave with a jumping spider as you are a new fish.

Owner Daryl and his staff are frequently praised for their patience and willingness to spend time with customers, especially families with kids. Multiple reviewers describe visits where staff answered extensive questions without rushing anyone toward a purchase. One customer noted that the owner's son spent considerable time walking a grandfather and grandson through setup requirements before they were ready to buy.

Custom ordering is available for those looking for something specific, and the store's pricing is generally considered reasonable compared to big-box alternatives. The fish selection leans freshwater, with customers reporting purchases of dwarf pea puffers and various community fish. At least one reviewer mentioned calling about saltwater filtration equipment, suggesting the store carries some saltwater gear.

Axolotls are a visible draw — several reviews mention kids being captivated by them on display. It's worth noting that the store has drawn pointed criticism, particularly around hermit crab care and husbandry information. Multiple reviewers have raised concerns about housing conditions, incorrect care advice given to customers, and the overall state of certain reptile and amphibian enclosures.

Some visitors have reported axolotls in poor condition with inadequate tank setups. These concerns appear across enough reviews to warrant attention from prospective buyers who should ask questions and assess animal health before purchasing. Parking downtown can be a deterrent for locals, but the store's character and personal service make it a distinct alternative to chain pet retailers in the Hendersonville area.

For freshwater fish, puffers, and exotic pets, it's worth the visit — just come prepared to evaluate the animals carefully.