About
A Reef Creation has earned a devoted following among saltwater hobbyists across western New York, and for good reason. Tucked into a Buffalo commercial plaza at entrance B — a detail newcomers should note — this specialized reef shop packs an impressive operation into its space. Multiple large coral tanks line the showroom, displaying everything from $10 frags to premium pieces running several hundred dollars.
The store sources its fish from Bali and the Red Sea, and they're known for their tank-raised clownfish alongside a broader saltwater fish selection that reviewers consistently praise. Owner Randy has built a reputation for going above and beyond for customers. One online buyer reported that the team took PAR readings on their behalf before shipping — the kind of detail-oriented service that speaks volumes about how seriously they take the hobby.
Packaging for shipped corals arrives meticulously done, with livestock arriving healthy and matching the photos. That level of care has made their online store a trusted option for reefers well beyond the Buffalo area. The coral selection is the clear star here.
Reviewers repeatedly describe it as beautiful and varied, with enough range to satisfy both newer reef keepers building out their first tank and seasoned collectors hunting for standout pieces. The shop also stocks the supplies and equipment needed to maintain a thriving reef system, making it a genuine one-stop destination for the saltwater community. Pricing draws mixed but mostly positive reactions — most find it reasonable or competitive, while some acknowledge prices run slightly higher but argue the quality justifies the cost.
Staff knowledge is the most consistent praise across reviews; these aren't salespeople reading labels, but experienced reefers who understand water chemistry, lighting, and coral care at a practical level. For the saltwater community in Buffalo and across New York State, A Reef Creation stands as a dedicated reef shop with the expertise, livestock quality, and customer commitment that serious hobbyists seek out.
What they offer
Livestock, services, water
- Livestock & products
- Services
- Specializes in
Highlights
What makes them special
- Extensive coral selection ranging from $10 frags to premium specimens
- Fish sourced from Bali and the Red Sea, including tank-raised clownfish
- Online store with meticulous packaging and nationwide shipping
- Staff provides hands-on technical support like PAR readings
- Widely regarded as the top saltwater shop in New York State
From keepers
Customer reviews
“amazing place. great customer service. knowledgeable staff. wonderful showroom. prices are great. cant ask for anything more from this place...”
— Tom Agen5.0Edited 2 days ago“Excellent customer service very knowledgeable and good prices. Would recommend to everyone.”
— Richard “Rick S” Schmigiel5.04 weeks ago“Best in area”
— Edward Cunningham5.04 weeks ago“Ordered online. Customer service was some of the best I’ve ever experienced. Went as far as to take PAR readings for me. Packaging was also top notch. Coral was as pictured and perfectly healthy upon arrival”
— Nick Lenzi5.03 months ago“Very knowledgeable staff, great prices.”
— Jennifer Norris5.03 months ago“Expert knowledge, Selection, Local Business. Beyond reasonable fish prices. All fish come from Bali and Red Sea. For the experienced hobbyist, need I say more. Myself as a business owner of Climate Diagnostics serving Buffalo for HVAC. Please support small businesses who helped create our beautiful home town”
— Brian Lorek5.03 months ago“Honestly the best place in all of New York to go to for anything saltwater. Randy is an absolute pleasure to work with and always makes time for his customers. I can’t say enough good things about this shop and their amazing selection. Prices are a bit high, but you wont find better quality in the state.”
— Josh Rivera5.04 months ago“Awesome selection of coral, fish and supplies. Great Customer Service.”
— Mike Morlock5.04 months ago“Well-priced, knowledgeable employees, and good stock of everything you would need to keep a reef tank.”
— Lance Dennis5.07 months ago“Very clued up staff. great experience and many options available to purchase great saltwater tank stock”
— Shannon Ogilvie5.07 months ago
Reference
Frequently asked questions
Note — Store information and services may change. Always call (716) 565-0700 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting A Reef Creation.