Fishstores.org
StatesBest StoresServicesNear meMapToolsGuidesSpecies
Fishstores.org

The most comprehensive directory of brick-and-mortar fish stores in the United States.

Find Fish Stores

  • Fish Stores Near Me
  • Browse by State
  • Best by Specialty
  • Stores by Service
  • Nationwide Store Map

Care Guides

  • Freshwater fish & shrimp
  • Saltwater & reef
  • Tanks & equipment
  • Troubleshooting
  • Browse all guides →
  • Species directory →

Resources

  • About Us
  • Email Us
  • Sitemap
© 2026 fishstores.org. All rights reserved.
Privacy PolicyTerms of ServiceAccessibility
  1. Home
  2. ›
  3. States
  4. ›
  5. Ohio
  6. ›
  7. Toledo
  8. ›
  9. The Fish Guys
The Fish Guys - Photo 1
The Fish Guys - Photo 2
The Fish Guys - Photo 3
The Fish Guys - Photo 4
The Fish Guys - Photo 5
+5 more
The Fish Guys - Photo 1
The Fish Guys - Photo 2
The Fish Guys - Photo 3
The Fish Guys - Photo 4
+6 more

Independent fish store · Toledo, OH

The Fish Guys

4.7· 485 reviews·Freshwater · Pond

1472 W Sylvania Ave, Toledo, OH 43612

Call · (419) 842-4272Get directionsVisit website

About

The Fish Guys is a freshwater fish store in Toledo, OH, at 1472 W Sylvania Ave, run by Matt and a team whose experience goes back to two earlier Toledo neighborhood shops, Pet Palace and Trilby Tropicals. The store describes itself as family owned and operated for over 40 years and is set up for aquarists rather than impulse buyers: no high-pressure selling, and an indoor koi pond with turtles that customers and their kids can feed with a handful of quarters while they browse. The livestock is freshwater only.

The stock list runs from community staples such as tetras, rasboras, barbs, danios, fancy guppies, platies, mollies and swordtails to angelfish, discus, gouramis, bettas, loaches, plecos and other catfish, puffers, rainbowfish, goldfish and both African and South American cichlids. Reviewers single out the cichlid selection, and the shop has held requested mbuna for an out-of-town customer until he could make the trip. Pond fish come in during pond season.

Freshwater shrimp for sale in Toledo, OH include Amano, red cherry, red rili, blue velvet, orange sunkist and yellow fire, alongside dwarf orange, electric blue and snowflake crayfish and snails, and a greatly expanded aquatic plant section gets regular new arrivals. Driftwood, hardscape, filters and the rest of the setup supplies fill the remaining shelves. Reviews describe the tanks as clean and the fish as consistently healthy, with several customers reporting years of purchases without a sick fish.

Matt and Todd field beginner questions on cycling, water parameters and stocking without pushing products, and have walked customers through water problems after the sale. Prices draw mixed comments: some call them reasonable, others find certain fish pricier than elsewhere. Charlie, the resident macaw, is mentioned almost as often as the fish.

Open seven days a week with evening hours on weekdays, The Fish Guys draws hobbyists from well beyond the city, with reviewers reporting three- and four-hour drives for the selection. For aquarium fish, plants and shrimp for sale in Toledo, it is the specialist freshwater fish store in town.

What they offer

Fish & livestock for sale at The Fish Guys in Toledo, OH

The Fish Guys stocks cichlids, African cichlids, angelfish, discus, shrimp, invertebrates, plecos, catfish, aquarium plants and freshwater & pond fish for sale in Toledo, OH. As a fish store serving Toledo, OH, it also carries aquarium equipment.

Livestock & products
CichlidsAfrican CichlidsAngelfishDiscusShrimpInvertebratesLive PlantsPlecosCatfishBettasGoldfishLivebearersTetrasPuffersAquarium Equipment
Specializes in
FreshwaterPond

Highlights

What makes them special

  • Freshwater-only specialist with African and South American cichlids, angelfish, discus, plecos and a deep community-fish list
  • Freshwater shrimp and crayfish selection: Amano, red cherry, blue velvet, orange sunkist, yellow fire and more
  • Regular aquatic plant arrivals plus driftwood, hardscape and setup supplies
  • Indoor koi and turtle pond customers can feed, and Charlie the resident macaw
  • Low-pressure, knowledgeable help from Matt and Todd on cycling, stocking and water problems

From keepers

Customer reviews

  • “These guys are super knowledgeable, helpful, and nice. Todd helped my Daughter pick out fish over 3 different occasions and even sang Happy Birthday when he realized it was that day. Thank you!”

    — Vincent Fenech5.0a day ago
  • “I have been a repeat customer for many years. The staff is consistently friendly and extremely knowledgeable. It is always a pleasure to visit and see the new fish in such a relaxing and calming atmosphere. I purchased some beautiful angelfish today, and they are very healthy and energetic.”

    — Joshua Rickard5.0Edited 5 days ago
  • “Great place to shop for fish or anything aquarium related. Everyone is very knowledgeable and helpful. The fish are always very healthy from here and I’ve never had an issue of a sick fish from them. Always happy when I go here.”

    — Zachary Morris5.02 weeks ago
  • “The best of the best. Quality goods and spot on knowledge!! Best of all it’s a great local small business!! Still stands true!!”

    — BIG DAN5.0Edited 2 weeks ago
  • “Great selection of fish maybe a little pricey but good people”

    — Jeff Miller4.02 weeks ago
  • “Very nice shop and super helpful love this place”

    — Sommer SombleWeed5.02 weeks ago
  • “The Fish Guys is the best local aquarium store in the area. Matt and his staff are extremely knowledgeable and friendly people. The shop itself has alot of personality with a inside pond for feeding fish/turtles. Even if you aren't into fish, its a great place to start or bring your kids to see all of the tanks. Highly Recommend!”

    — Alex Merritt5.03 weeks ago
  • “Very unfriendly and no help at all”

    — Sharon Hamilton1.0a month ago
  • “I used to go to those franchise pet stores, nowadays I’m always thrilled and excited when I know I will be coming to The Fish Guy! They know their fish, provide great customer service, and being to educate when asked for further information! 5/5, I highly recommend💪🏿💪🏿💪🏿”

    — Mohamed-Abdul King5.0Edited a month ago
  • “Very interesting place. I will be going back”

    — Blue Diamond5.0a month ago

Reference

Frequently asked questions

Note — Store information and services may change. Always call (419) 842-4272 to confirm current availability, hours, and services before visiting The Fish Guys.

Hours

Mon
11 AM–7 PM
Tue
11 AM–7 PM
Wed
11 AM–7 PM
Thu
11 AM–7 PM
Fri
11 AM–7 PM
Sat
11 AM–6 PM
Sun
11 AM–5 PM

Contact

Phone
(419) 842-4272
Website
www.fishyguy.com/
Address
1472 W Sylvania Ave, Toledo, OH 43612
Facebook·Instagram

On the map

Open in Google Maps
Own this store? Claim it

Updated October 24, 2026

More in Toledo

Other shops nearby

No. 01

Coral Freaks

5.0
Toledo, OHSaltwaterVisit listing
No. 02

Method Aquatics

4.9
Toledo, OHFreshwater · SaltwaterVisit listing
No. 03

Agnoquatics

4.9
Broadview Heights, OHFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 04

Aquarium Services Inc.

4.9
Willoughby, OHFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 05

Aquascapes Tropical Fish

4.9
Dayton, OHFreshwaterVisit listing
No. 06

Fresh Tides Aquatics

4.9
Cincinnati, OHFreshwaterVisit listing