Fishstores.org
  • Tools
  • States
  • Map
  • Near Me
  • Search
fishstores.org

The most comprehensive directory of brick-and-mortar fish stores in the United States.

Find Fish Stores

  • Fish Stores Near Me
  • Browse by State
  • Nationwide Store Map

Resources

  • About Us
  • Email Us
  • Sitemap
© 2025 fishstores.org. All rights reserved.
Privacy PolicyTerms of ServiceAccessibility
  1. States
  2. Illinois
  3. Midlothian
  4. Animal Island Pet Shop

Animal Island Pet Shop

14411 S Cicero Ave, Midlothian, IL 60445, USA
Highly Rated
4.7(1352 reviews)
Closed• 10AM-7PM
unknown
Call (708) 293-0600Get DirectionsVisit Website
Animal Island Pet Shop is a paradise for pet lovers, offering an extensive selection of both exotic and domestic animals. With a focus on superior pet care products and a team of knowledgeable staff, the store guarantees an exceptional shopping experience. Customers are drawn to its outstanding customer service and the wide variety of animals available, making it a must-visit destination for pet enthusiasts.

Loading map...

View on Google Maps
Store Photos10 photos
Animal Island Pet Shop - Main photo
Click to view full size
Animal Island Pet Shop - Photo 2
Animal Island Pet Shop - Photo 3
Animal Island Pet Shop - Photo 4
Hours & Contact

Store Hours

Monday:10AM-7PM
Tuesday:10AM-7PM
Wednesday:10AM-7PM
Thursday:10AM-7PM
Friday:10AM-7PM
Saturday:10AM-6PM
Sunday:10AM-6PM

Contact Information

Phone

(708) 293-0600

Website

www.animalislandpets.com/

Address

14411 S Cicero Ave, Midlothian, IL 60445, USA

Customer Reviews
4.7(1352)

Uncle Dirt

These people are incredibly nice. I live in New Lenox. This means I passed up quite a few pet centers that sell fish. I did so to support a small business. I was not disappointed. They set me up with fish that they knew would get along in my 125-gallon tank. I followed their advice on introducing them to their new environment. They are all exploring and thriving right now. I'll never go anywhere else.

Nina G

This place is simply amazing! It has any exotic pet you would desire! They have great customer service!! They are very informative on all the animals. Their diets, habitats, origins and how to care for your pet. They also sell tanks, enclosure, cages and more! My son loves his Bearded Dragon! I definitely RECOMMEND!! Oh and don’t forget to bring the kids along it’s like a mini field trip!!!

nicole kainz

Jason is amazing and runs his shop 👌 The only downfall is Midlothian is about a 45min drive for me, but with feeders you get various qualities with good & REASONABLE prices !!! My boyfriend and I have been going to his brother's store out in Lockport for years but unfortunately they are closing so Jason's will be our go to spot !!

My Life - DIY

It's worth a visit just to see all the beautiful 😍 fish! Super friendly staff, great prices. Got a cool fishtank and new baby rat 🐀. His name is Jack! The staff was super helpful and so patient, letting me pick just the right one out. Love the bulk small animal food and huge live and dry bug selection! I'll definitely be back. It was worth the trip!

The Laboy Twins

When I was first walked into this pet shop looking for a new pet because my tarantula died I was amazed! Fish, Lizards, Tarantulas, Snakes, and everything else I could have ever imagined! They had every supply I needed to get a crested gecko. Then that died 2 weeks later of a molting issue but then I got a leopard gecko and two days ago I came back for another leopard gecko. And those purchases are certainly purchases I don’t regret making.

Own this business?

Take control of your listing to update info and respond to reviews.

Claim This Listing
About This Store

Fish store specializing in tropical and freshwater species, as well as reptiles.

Information Updated

July 26, 2025

Verified Data

Information verified through Google Places API and community contributions.