---
type: category_state
category: "Rare Species"
state: "NY"
stores: 22
url: https://www.fishstores.org/best/rare-species/new-york
---

# Best Rare Species Fish Stores in New York

22 stores specializing in rare, exotic, and hard-to-find fish species in New York

## Stores

### 1. [Aquatic Haven](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/fulton/aquatic-haven)

- **Address**: 370B W 1st St S, Fulton, NY 13069
- **Phone**: (315) 887-5035
- **Rating**: 5.0/5 (41 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Bettas, Plecos, Live Plants, Invertebrates, Shrimp, Aquarium Equipment, Fish Food, Rare Species, Axolotls
- **Website**: [listindexusa.org/details/aquatic-haven-ChIJw55](https://listindexusa.org/details/aquatic-haven-ChIJw55)

### 2. [Fluid Dynamics Aquarium Services and Store](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/deer-park/fluid-dynamics-aquarium-services-and-store)

- **Address**: 832 Grand Blvd, Deer Park, NY 11729
- **Phone**: (631) 208-5302
- **Rating**: 5.0/5 (126 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater
- **Specializations**: African Cichlids, Cichlids, Live Plants, Planted Tanks, Corals, Reef, Rare Species, Plecos, Shrimp, Invertebrates, Clownfish, Aquarium Equipment
- **Website**: [fluiddynamicsinternational.com/](http://fluiddynamicsinternational.com/)

### 3. [City Island Aquarium Tropical Fish Sales](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/bronx/city-island-aquarium-tropical-fish-sales)

- **Address**: 316 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464
- **Phone**: (914) 303-3474
- **Rating**: 5.0/5 (23 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Shrimp, Puffers, Cichlids, Bettas, Live Plants, Invertebrates, Reef, Rare Species
- **Website**: [www.instagram.com/cityisland_aquariumstore](https://www.instagram.com/cityisland_aquariumstore)

### 4. [Complete Aquarium](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/bedford-hills/complete-aquarium)

- **Address**: 736 Bedford Rd, Bedford Hills, NY 10507
- **Phone**: (914) 244-9174
- **Rating**: 4.9/5 (330 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Corals, Reef, Bettas, Invertebrates, Rare Species, Live Plants, Aquarium Equipment
- **Website**: [www.completeaqua.com/](http://www.completeaqua.com/)

### 5. [Underground Aquaticz](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/west-babylon/underground-aquaticz)

- **Address**: 185 Great East Neck Rd, West Babylon, NY 11704
- **Phone**: (631) 422-1470
- **Rating**: 4.9/5 (110 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater
- **Specializations**: Cichlids, African Cichlids, Discus, Shrimp, Live Plants, Arowanas, Plecos, Puffers, Rare Species, Angelfish
- **Website**: [www.undergroundaquaticz.com/](https://www.undergroundaquaticz.com/)

### 6. [Reef Shark Aquarium Inc](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/east-meadow/reef-shark-aquarium-inc)

- **Address**: 2083 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow, NY 11554
- **Phone**: (516) 750-5011
- **Rating**: 4.9/5 (42 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Corals, Reef, Invertebrates, Tangs, Clownfish, Rare Species
- **Website**: [rsacorals.com/](http://rsacorals.com/)

### 7. [Overboard Aquatics](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/port-jervis/overboard-aquatics)

- **Address**: 124 Jersey Ave, Port Jervis, NY 12771
- **Phone**: (845) 672-3559
- **Rating**: 4.9/5 (75 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Corals, Live Plants, Reef, Invertebrates, Axolotls, Rare Species
- **Website**: [www.overboardaquatics.com/](https://www.overboardaquatics.com/)

### 8. [Buckley's Fish Room](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/ballston-spa/buckleys-fish-room)

- **Address**: 2031 Doubleday Ave, Ballston Spa, NY 12020
- **Phone**: (518) 309-3905
- **Rating**: 4.7/5 (300 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Corals, Live Plants, Axolotls, Clownfish, Aquarium Equipment, Planted Tanks, Rare Species

### 9. [PREDATORY FINS](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/copiague/predatory-fins)

- **Address**: 750 Montauk Hwy, Copiague, NY 11726
- **Phone**: (561) 430-7944
- **Rating**: 4.7/5 (433 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Puffers, Plecos, Catfish, Rare Species, Arowanas
- **Website**: [www.predatoryfins.com/](http://www.predatoryfins.com/)

### 10. [Michael's NYAquatic](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/yonkers/michaels-nyaquatic)

- **Address**: 145 Saw Mill River Rd, Yonkers, NY 10701
- **Phone**: (914) 690-6706
- **Rating**: 4.7/5 (226 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Rare Species, Corals, Tangs, Clownfish
- **Website**: [www.nyaquatic.com/](http://www.nyaquatic.com/)

### 11. [Aquarium Solutions 101](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/wappingers-falls/aquarium-solutions-101)

- **Address**: 900 NY-376 suite MNO, Wappingers Falls, NY 12590
- **Phone**: (845) 518-4779
- **Rating**: 4.7/5 (95 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Corals, Reef, Live Plants, Planted Tanks, Tetras, Rare Species, Dry Goods, Fish Food, Medications
- **Website**: [www.aquariumsolutions101.com/](http://www.aquariumsolutions101.com/)

### 12. [Eddie's Aquarium Centre](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/cohoes/eddies-aquarium-centre)

- **Address**: 1254 Loudon Rd, Cohoes, NY 12047
- **Phone**: (518) 783-3474
- **Rating**: 4.6/5 (838 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Live Plants, Tetras, Koi, Shrimp, Rare Species, Bettas, Aquarium Equipment, Fish Food, Medications, Dry Goods
- **Website**: [www.eddiesaqua.com/](http://www.eddiesaqua.com/)

### 13. [ABC Reefs](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/solvay/abc-reefs)

- **Address**: Geddes Plaza, 527 Charles Ave, Solvay, NY 13209
- **Phone**: (315) 882-0778
- **Rating**: 4.6/5 (258 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Corals, Anemones, Live Plants, Live Rock, Invertebrates, Rare Species, Plecos
- **Website**: [abcreefs.com/](https://abcreefs.com/)

### 14. [Coral Sea Aquatics](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/orchard-park/coral-sea-aquatics)

- **Address**: 5421 S Abbott Rd, Orchard Park, NY 14127
- **Phone**: (716) 202-1165
- **Rating**: 4.6/5 (264 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Corals, Anemones, Angelfish, Catfish, Plecos, Tetras, Live Plants, Clownfish, Rare Species, Aquarium Equipment
- **Website**: [coralseawny.com/](http://coralseawny.com/)

### 15. [The Fish Place](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/north-tonawanda/the-fish-place)

- **Address**: 141 Robinson St, North Tonawanda, NY 14120
- **Phone**: (716) 693-4411
- **Rating**: 4.6/5 (1400 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater, Brackish, Pond
- **Specializations**: Live Plants, Corals, Bettas, Shrimp, Rare Species, Planted Tanks, Dry Goods, Aquarium Equipment, Fish Food
- **Website**: [facebook.com/tfpnt/](https://facebook.com/tfpnt/)

### 16. [Tropical Showcase](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/hicksville/tropical-showcase)

- **Address**: 372 W Old Country Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801
- **Phone**: (516) 433-0988
- **Rating**: 4.5/5 (280 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Bettas, Axolotls, Live Plants, Plecos, Angelfish, Aquarium Equipment, Rare Species
- **Website**: [tropicalshowcase.com/](http://tropicalshowcase.com/)

### 17. [Jawz Aquarium](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/elmsford/jawz-aquarium)

- **Address**: 75 N Saw Mill River Rd, Elmsford, NY 10523
- **Phone**: (914) 345-5855
- **Rating**: 4.5/5 (84 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Corals, Reef, Tangs, Plecos, Shrimp, Invertebrates, Live Rock, Aquarium Equipment, Dry Goods, Rare Species
- **Website**: [www.jawz.net/](http://www.jawz.net/)

### 18. [Amazing Aquarium](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/brooklyn/amazing-aquarium)

- **Address**: 2136 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11214
- **Phone**: (718) 996-0171
- **Rating**: 4.5/5 (383 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater
- **Specializations**: Cichlids, African Cichlids, Arowanas, Tetras, Bettas, Shrimp, Invertebrates, Live Plants, Livebearers, Rare Species, Goldfish

### 19. [Country Critters Ltd](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/patchogue/country-critters-ltd)

- **Address**: 152 Medford Ave, Patchogue, NY 11772
- **Phone**: (631) 758-6777
- **Rating**: 4.5/5 (1039 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater, Pond
- **Specializations**: Reef, Corals, Discus, Rare Species, Live Plants, Invertebrates
- **Website**: [www.countrycritterspets.com/](http://www.countrycritterspets.com/)

### 20. [Kissena Aquarium Inc](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/flushing/kissena-aquarium-inc)

- **Address**: 46-30 Kissena Blvd, Flushing, NY 11355, USA
- **Phone**: (718) 358-0761
- **Rating**: 4.4/5 (323 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater
- **Specializations**: Corals, Cichlids, Bettas, Axolotls, Live Plants, Invertebrates, Shrimp, Goldfish, Koi, Tetras, Catfish, Livebearers, Tangs, Rare Species, Aquarium Equipment, Fish Food, Medications
- **Website**: [m.facebook.com/NewKissenaAquarium/](https://m.facebook.com/NewKissenaAquarium/)

### 21. [Pete's Aquariums & Fish](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/fishkill/petes-aquariums-and-fish)

- **Address**: 973 Main St, Fishkill, NY 12524
- **Phone**: (917) 405-9428
- **Rating**: 4.3/5 (165 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater, Saltwater, Pond
- **Specializations**: Corals, Tangs, Live Plants, Invertebrates, Rare Species, Medications
- **Website**: [www.petesaquariums.com/](http://www.petesaquariums.com/)

### 22. [Monster Aquarium Inc - Shop in Queens New York](https://www.fishstores.org/new-york/flushing/monster-aquarium-inc-shop-in-queens-new-york)

- **Address**: 131-08 40th Rd, Flushing, NY 11354
- **Phone**: (347) 732-0373
- **Rating**: 4.2/5 (986 reviews)
- **Water Types**: Freshwater
- **Specializations**: Rare Species, Arowanas, Discus, Axolotls, Live Plants, Shrimp, Tetras, Cichlids, Aquarium Equipment
- **Website**: [www.monsteraquariumon9.com/](http://www.monsteraquariumon9.com/)

---
*Source: [FishStores.org](https://www.fishstores.org/best/rare-species/new-york)*